Random thoughts on almost anything and everything, with an emphasis on defense, intelligence, politics and national security matters..providing insight for the non-cleared world since 2005.
Monday, April 21, 2008
The Latest Salvo
Today, Secretary Gates took his criticism of the USAF to a new level--and venue--delivering a stinging critique at the very Citadel of airpower, Maxwell AFB, Alabama. Speaking to students at Air University, Gates said the Air Force is not doing enough to help in the war zones and complained that some military leaders are "stuck in old ways of doing business."
Getting the service to send more intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance (ISR) aircraft to Iraq and Afghanistan has been "like pulling teeth," Gates observed. He said the Air Force's desire to use pilots and aircrews for "its own missions" have kept the Pentagon from using larger numbers of unmanned aircraft.
“In my view we can do and we should do more to meet the needs of men and women fighting in the current conflicts while their outcome may still be in doubt,” he said. “My concern is that our services are still not moving aggressively in wartime to provide resources needed now on the battlefield.”
The Pentagon chief praised the Air Force for its overall contributions but made a point of urging it to do more and to undertake more creative ways of thinking about helping the war effort.
While Gates’ comments were directed mainly at the Air Force, his concern about faster fielding of unmanned surveillance and reconnaissance aircraft included a broader appeal to the entire military. The Army, Navy and Marine Corps have been expanding their fleets of drone aircraft.
"I've been wrestling for months to get more intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance assets into the theater," Gates told officer students at the war college.
[snip]
Today we now have more than 5,000 UAVs, a 25-fold increase since 2001," Gates said. "But in my view we can do and we should do more to meet the needs of men and women fighting in the current conflicts while their outcome may still be in doubt."
Responding to the secretary's speech, a Pentagon official told NBC News, "We're still scratching our heads over this one...we've done everything possible to open the floodgates and get everything to the battlefield as soon as possible." The official, who spoke on the condition of anonymity, said there are no additional UAVs available for deployment. Air Force officials have also stated that there isn't enough bandwidth to handle video down links from increased drone flights and the basing of additional drones would create parking problems at forward bases.
The secretary's comments at Maxwell represent the latest salvo in struggle over UAV operations that has become bitter in recent months. Gates' efforts to double the number of drone orbits in Iraq and Afghanistan has placed a severe burden on Air Force UAV units, making it difficult to support increased operations.
In some cases, drone pilots have found themselves stuck in their assignments, delaying their return to manned aircraft and decreasing prospects for promotion and advancement. The Air Force considers UAV assignments as special duty positions, filled by pilots who normally fly other aircraft, and return to their primary platforms once that tour is complete.
Commanders of UAV units have also voiced concerns that the "surge" in drone flights--in support of expanded ground operations--will undermine efforts to train new UAV crews. One Air Force study, circulated in recent weeks, warned that drone units were facing an internal collapse, akin to that of the German Luftwaffe in World War II. In the closing days of that conflict, German squadrons were so strained by daily operations that they were unable to adequately train new pilots. As experienced fliers were lost in combat, their units simply collapsed.
The forum--and location--for Mr. Gates' response was also rooted in history. Air University, based at Maxwell, has led the formulation of Air Force doctrine for decades. The historic base has long been at the forefront of Air Force policy and operational development, dating back to the Army Air Corps Tactical School of the 1930s, which advanced the precision bombing strategy used in World War II.
Mr. Gates' speech contained several references to "maverick" and "creative thinking, suggesting that the Air Force needs to rethink its doctrine, operational priorities and acquisition plans. Delivering his address to Air War College students, the defense secretary seemed to direct his appeal to the "next" generation of Air Force leaders, officers who will move into flag billets in the coming years.
The war college represents the highest level of military education for career officers; virtually all Air Force generals attend the 10-month course, or one of the sister schools run by the other services. Tailoring his remarks to future generals, Gates seemed to suggest that the current generation of Air Force leaders is too resistant to change.
Gates also used his address to highlight plans for pushing the UAV issue even harder. He reminded the students that he recently established a DOD task force to work the problem and "find more innovative ways to help those whose lives are on the line."
Ironically, creation of that organization represented another rebuke to the Air Force. Last year, Mr. Gates rejected the service's bid to become executive agent for the military's drone programs, giving it greater authority in the employment and acquisition of new UAVs and the intelligence networks they support. The task force created by the defense secretary will give the other services a greater voice in those issues.
However, the secretary's comments did not address a related controversy--is the dramatic increase in drone flights really necessary? While Gates would argue that the recent spike in UAV sorties is imperative, Air Force leaders have their doubts, triggering the disagreement that has become a public feud.
In a speech delivered last summer, the commander of the service's Air Combat Command, General Ron Keys, claimed that using UAVs to hunt for IEDs--a critical assignment in Iraq--represents a waste of time and resources. Speaking to a defense industry audience in Virginia, General Keys said that drones had detected only a "handful" of roadside bombs and suggested that the unmanned aircraft might be better utilized for other tasks.
While Keys' remarks received little publicity, they are believed to mirror those of other USAF officials, who have opposed Gates UAV employment plan. At one point, Mr. Gates reportedly proposed 30 drone orbits per day for Iraq and Afghanistan, providing persistent surveillance that ground commanders requested. But the Air Force balked at that figure, claiming it was not sustainable.
Since then, the service and the defense chief have compromised on a lower total, about two dozen orbits a day. Senior Air Force officials claim that any further increase in operations would over-stress UAV units that are already stretched thin, and make it nearly impossible to train replacement crews.
Medium and high-altitude UAVs like the Predator, Reaper and Global Hawk utilize a two-man crew, consisting of a pilot and an enlisted sensor operator. Video collected by the onboard sensors are transmitted to large intelligence organizations, part of the Distributed Common Ground System (DCGS). The number of DCGS units is also small, putting another limit on the number of UAV missions that can be flown each day.
Sunday, April 20, 2008
Accountability, Anyone?
At the top of that list was the "Thunder-Vision" scandal, charges that senior officers tried to steer a contract for video screens to a company that included a retired four-star general among its partners. The screens were to be used to "jazz up" airshows that featured the USAF Thunderbirds, the service's world-famous, precision-flying team.
And sure enough, the Air Force awarded a $50 million contract to the company (Strategic Message Solutions) in December 2005--despite the fact that the firm's offer was more than twice as expensive as a competing bid. The service also ignored the precedent established by the Navy's Blue Angels, who received video screens for free, in exchange for selling advertising on their projection system during air shows. The SMS contract was later cancelled, after protests from rival firms.
The Pentagon and the FBI spent more than two years investigating "Thunder Vision." A copy of their report was obtained by the Washington Post, and some of the findings are damning. Consider the role played by Major General Stephen Goldfein in steering the video screen contract to SMS, as recounted by Post reporter Josh White:
Sitting at the head of the table, Air Force Maj. Gen. Stephen Goldfein, the highest-ranking officer in the room, leaned forward and told the officers and others assembled before him that they should steer a multimillion-dollar Air Force contract to a company named Strategic Message Solutions.
"I don't pick the winner, but if I did, I'd pick SMS," Goldfein said to the seven-person group that was selecting a contractor to jazz up the Air Force's Thunderbirds air show with giant video boards, according to a lengthy report by Defense Department's inspector general. The head of the selection team almost immediately "caved," giving in to what he believed was a fixed process, while another member of the team called it "the dirtiest thing" he had ever experienced
[snip]
In a probe that lasted more than two years, investigators concluded that Goldfein and others worked inside the Air Force contracting system to favor SMS and its owners, despite an offer by the company that was more than twice as expensive as a competing bid.
Goldfein, who is now vice director of the Pentagon's Joint Staff, was found to have gone to great lengths to see the contract awarded to SMS, while senior Air Force leaders socialized with the company's partners. According to the report, Goldfein even arranged for President Bush to record a video testimonial in the White House Map Room that was included in the SMS contract proposal, demonstrating the company's credibility and access.
The report offers a blow-by-blow account of how a small Air Force contract spun out of control, highlighting conflicts of interest in the selection process, officers stacking the deck in favor of friends, and others influencing a system designed to eliminate such favoritism in spending taxpayer dollars.
"The investigation found that the December 2005 award to SMS was tainted with improper influence, irregular procurement practices, and preferential treatment," according to a redacted copy of the report. "Lower priced offers from qualified vendors and capabilities in-house were bypassed in an apparent effort to obtain services from [redacted], president of SMS, who had a longstanding relationship with senior Air Force officers and members of the Thunderbirds."
According to the Post, Goldfein and four other unidentified officers have received administrative punishment. Reporter Erik Holmes of Air Force Times has also been on the story, and reveals that General Goldfein received a letter of reprimand. At the flag level, that probably enough to derail the general's career. However, at last report Goldfein was still in his job as Vice Director of the Pentagon's Joint Staff, and other Air Force generals have survived similar mistakes and continued to advance in rank.
In one case, two senior officers were nominated for their second star, despite being fired from previous positions. And just last week, the service announced that one of those officers, Major General Mark Shackleford, has been selected for promotion to Lieutenant General. His advancement--which is subject to confirmation by the Senate--comes less than six years after he was dismissed as head of the F-22 program office, due to massive cost over-runs in the stealth fighter program.
Despite being removed from his post (normally a career-killer for senior officers) Shackleford's name subsequently appeared on the nomination list for major general, and he's now in line for his third star. Will the Air Force attempt a similar rehabilitation for Goldfein? Only time will tell.
What the Post and Air Force Times fail to note (at least in the referenced article) is that Goldfein continued his climb, despite ties to the Thunder-Vision controversy. At the time the contract was awarded, General Goldfein was Commander of the Air Warfare Center at Nellis AFB--home of the Thunderbirds. One of the partners in the company that won the contract was retired General Hal Hornburg, the former Commander of Air Combat Command (ACC).
As the head of ACC, Hornburg was in charge of CONUS-based fighter, bomber and combat training units, including the Air Warfare Center. Goldfein's assignment to Nellis (from October 2004-October 2006) was almost certainly cleared through Hornburg, who retired as the ACC Commander in January 2005, almost a year before the contract was awarded.
Despite concerns about the contract--and Goldfein's efforts to influence the selection process--he advanced to more important jobs in the military hierarchy. In November 2006, he moved to Langley AFB, Virginia, to a new assignment as Vice Commander of ACC. Barely four months later, General Goldfein was transferred to Washington, D.C., and his current position as Vice Director of the Joint Staff.
Those assignments raise serious questions for both the Air Force and the Defense Department. At the time of his reassignment to Langley, Goldfein was apparently under investigation for his role in the "Thunder Vision" contract, and the probe continued during his subsequent tour at the Pentagon. If he was under investigation--and there's nothing in the Post account or Air Force statements to indicate he wasn't--then why did General Goldfein keep moving up the ladder?
Certainly, the investigation was anything but a secret; media accounts of the probe date back more than two years. We can also assume that key Air Force leaders were aware of the investigation (and may have received periodic updates on its status) but did nothing to delay General Goldfein's advancement. The list of officers and officials in that category would likely include General Ron Keys, who succeeded Hornburg as ACC Commander; General Michael Moseley, the Air Force Chief of Staff and the Air Force Secretary, Michael Wynne.
To be fair, we should point out that general officers are occasionally the subject of frivolous complaints and investigations, often the result of complaints by disgruntled subordinates. A case in point is the allegation of infidelity, leveled at General Michael Hayden, during his tenure as head of the National Security Agency. Hayden was accused of having an affair with a female subordinate, during a visit to Kosovo several years ago. The charge was completely groundless, but it still had to be investigated, so an Air Force Colonel spent several months probing the matter.
But the allegations in this case are anything but frivolous. And, judging by the results of the investigation, it seems clear that senior Air Force officials tried to steer the "Thunder Vision" contract to a firm headed by a retired four-star general. General Goldfein left no doubt about his preference in the matter, while carefully noting that the final decision was not up to him.
Still, as Air Force Times reports, Goldfein lobbied actively on behalf of SMS:
The investigation report shows that a number of Goldfein’s actions appeared to steer the contract to SMS, and some members of the source-selection team told government investigators they did not think the process was fair.
For example, Goldfein told the contracting officer the winner of the competition should already be familiar with the Thunderbirds, so the officer elevated “strategic insight” to one of the top two criteria — up from its original status as a subcategory, according to the report.
The report says this tipped the scale in SMS’s favor. It is “reasonable to infer that Goldfein knew or should have known that his recommendation provided advantage to [Shipley],” the report states.
Three team members recalled Goldfein saying during a team meeting, “I’m not the [source-selection authority], but if I was the SSA, I’d select SMS,” according to the report.
Goldfein told investigators he does not recall saying that.
In a Nov. 8 meeting during which the final decision was made, the report says, Goldfein argued for team members to select SMS.
The Times also notes that General Goldfein even attempted--at one point--to become a part of the decision-making team. Told he could not serve in that capacity, Goldfein became an advisor to the selection panel, and according to the IG, tried to steer the contract toward SMS.
In addition to Goldfein, the company had other, high-ranking Air Force officials in its corner. As part of their investigation, IG representatives interviewed General Moseley, the Chief of Staff. Turns out that Moseley has a personal relationship with Ed Shipley, a wealthy infomercial producer--and vintage aircraft enthusiast--who was the other principal in SMS.
While the report contains no information that Moseley had contact with Goldfein or anyone else involved in the contract (after the video screen project was opened up for bids), it does include numerous e-mails and social gatherings during that time, involving General Moseley, Horburg and Shipley. As Air Force Times describes the contacts:
Some of those e-mails could be construed as discussing the Thunderbirds project. But Moseley said they addressed other issues.
For example, Moseley sent Hornburg an e-mail July 20: “I’ve engaged with a couple other guys around here to hopefully get a better response to the idea of public media outreach. We’ll see.”
Moseley said the e-mail does not refer to the Thunderbirds project.
On Aug. 10, Moseley e-mailed Shipley: “I’d like to run an idea or two by you to see how you react! I’m still wrestling with brand ideas and how to think through the options.”
Then on Sept. 22, Moseley sent Shipley another e-mail: “Dude ... I’ve talked to lawyers about your idea and I’ve talked to contracting bubbas about getting on with planned good ideas and I’ve got a way huge notion of building a better strategic communication effort. ... I want to chat with you about all this to see what you think.”
Investigators asked Moseley what he meant by this e-mail, and he said he was not referring to the Thunderbirds project.
An Air Force official familiar with the report told Air Force Times the e-mail refers not to the Thunderbirds project, but to Shipley’s idea to use paid advertising in Air Force strategic communications and outreach efforts to offset the costs to the service.
The report also contains an e-mail exchange in which Moseley asks Shipley to give a friend a ride in an aircraft at a Heritage Flight show.
[snip]
Moseley told Air Force Times that none of his contacts with Hornburg and Shipley was inappropriate, though he could have taken more steps to curtail his contact with them while the Thunderbirds project competition was ongoing.
“In perfect hindsight, then I would tell you ... yeah, I guess I could have been less receptive or less friendly,” he said.
In hindsight, you'd also think that Moseley could have offered similar advice to General Goldfein. But, if the Chief had his own ethical issues with "Thunder Vision," he wasn't in a position to caution Goldfein--or anyone else--about lobbying on behalf of SMS.
That's why this whole mess stinks to high heaven. And, there's more dirt in the details of the contract and its execution. A contracting officer who was interviewed by investigators revealed that SMS never provided the detailed financial documents required. There is also no evidence that the firm had the facilities to produce material that would be shown on the video screens.
And, just two days after it received the contract, SMS submitted a $2 million invoice for achieving "Milestone One," despite the fact that no services had been received, according to the IG.
Shipley told Goldfein the money was needed to ensure there would be no delays, the report says. Goldfein then called the contracting officer urging him to expedite payment, even though government contracting rules say payment due dates are 30 days after receipt of an invoice or 30 days after services are received, whichever is later.
Goldfein denied he had the payment expedited.P>
>Shipley also was allowed to use Air Force personnel and facilities to do the work, according to the report, both of which were prohibited by the contract.
We should note that no one will face criminal charges in connection with the contract. The U.S. Attorney's Office in Nevada declined to prosecute, due to a "lack of evidence of criminal wrong-doing," according to a statement. So, the only sanctions will be the LOR received by General Goldfein, and administrative punishments given to other, lower-ranking personnel involved in the scandal.
But there's also the matter of public trust and perception. When this scandal was first reported, we had a conversation with a senior Air Force civilian, an individual who's literally hard-wired into the service's upper echelons. At the time, he told us that the USAF was viewed as "lower than whale s--t" at the highest levels of the Pentagon, due to a (seemingly) endless parade of scandals and ethical lapses. Needless to say, the IG report won't exactly endear the Air Force to the current Secretary of Defense, Robert Gates.
Which brings us to the real bottom-line in this matter. The two-year investigation into the "Thunder Vision" controversy suggests an Air Force acquisition/contracting process that remains badly broken, and beset by favoritism and cronyism. Goldfein and Moseley are highly experienced officers and no strangers to service rules on ethical conduct.
Yet, Goldfein had no problem lobbying on behalf of SMS, and Moseley maintained social ties with the firm's CEO--while it was actively soliciting an multi-million dollar Air Force contract. Then, there's the matter of those e-mails. With all due respect to the chief of staff, his explanation about their content seems less-than-convincing. With Shipley (and Hornburg's firm) pushing hard for the video screen deal, it's hard to imagine that the topic never came up in communications with the service's senior officer. We'd say the e-mails were just carefully worded, in case the contract attracted controversy.
One of the fundamental rules in ethical behavior is one of the simplest: don't put yourself--or your organization--in a compromising position. But, Generals Goldfein and Moseley did just that, going to bat for a company that included a former colleague and commander among its partners. And they apparently saw nothing wrong with that.
Their conduct speaks volumes about an Air Force hierarchy that has grown increasingly cynical and corrupt in recent years. One of the service's great enlisted leaders (now retired) refers to them as the GOBAGS--the Good Ole Boys (and Girls) who dominate the upper ranks and form a mutal protective association. When one of them steps out of line (read: gets caught), a slap on the wrist is administered, and the system keeps lurching along.
That's why Mr. Gates needs to be proactive in addressing the service's integrity issue. The Air Force is long due for a thorough house-cleaning. We'd say that Mr. Gates could get everyone's attention by dismissing Moseley, Goldfein and Secretary Mike Wynne, who expressed "disappointment" over the chicanery revealed in the IG report.
Judging from the fallout in the Thunder Vision scandal (or the lack thereof), the Air Force has lost the ability to police its senior ranks. That's why Mr. Gates needs to step in and reset the service's ethical compass. The soul of the USAF is on the line. We can only hope that Mr. Gates, who began his public service career as an Air Force intelligence officer, will do the right thing--for the Air Force, and for the nation.Saturday, April 19, 2008
Unimpressive
According to the Tehran Times, at least 200 aircraft took part in the event. That would be more than the number expected, if the paper's estimate is correct.
But, as we noted in our preview of the air parade, the aircraft displayed were decidedly old. When the highlight clip begins with 35-year-old F-4 Phantoms, well, your "parade" is more a heritage flight than a display of military might. And sure enough, the Phantom fly-by was followed by other aging aircraft, including U.S.-built "Huey" helicopters.
As expected, the Iranian Air Force used the event to showcase its "new" Saegeh fighters, but that jet is nothing more than a rebuilt F-5 (acquired from the U.S. in the 1960s), with slightly upgraded avionics and a second vertical stabilizer. A highlight clip from the parade (courtesy of the MediaLine) shows three of the "new" fighters, which may represent most of Saegehs currently operational in the Iranian Air Force.
Along with the aircraft, this year's Army Day parade also featured other types of military equipment, including battlefield missiles and rockets, and at least one Shahab-3 medium-range ballistic missile, capble of striking Israel. From the video clip, we couldn't tell if the transporter-erector-launcher (TEL) vehicle was a new model, or one of the older ones.
The distinction is important; according to western missile experts, Iran's early Shahab-3 TELs could not elevate a fueled missile to the launch position. That would require Iranian crews to erect the missile and fuel it before firing, lengthening the launch cycle and increasing their vulnerability to detection and attack.
Friday's event also featured a speech by Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, filled with the usual blather. Here are a few "highlights." Spew alert: put down your glass or swallow your beverage before you read these howlers:
Addressing the ceremony, President Mahmud Ahmadinejad described the army as a “strong citadel” and “unrivaled defensive power” against the enemies’ threats.
He said, “Iran is the most powerful and popular nation in the world” whose “efforts and achievements are at the service of human excellence, peace, and friendship”.
“Iran is now so powerful that none of the world’s hegemonic powers are capable of threatening its security,” he stated.
At least the rhetoric of Iran's president matched the equipment on display. Nothing new (as far as we could tell), and decidedly unimpressive.
Thursday, April 17, 2008
Unlikely Sources
However, we will give Stephanopoulous credit for at least listening to conservative voices. Serving as co-moderator of last night's Democratic Presidential Debate in Philadelphia, Mr. Stephanopoulous apparently drew on some unlikely sources for two of his questions--talk show host Sean Hannity and conservative columnist Charles Krauthammer.
The queries, directed first to Senator Barack Obama, focused on a proposed extension of the U.S. nuclear umbrella to Israel, and the his personal relationship with former Weather Underground terrorist Bill Ayers.
When we heard the question about Mr. Ayers, we almost fell off the couch. Barely 24 hours earlier, Stephanopoulous had been discussing the issue on Sean Hannity's radio show. When Mr. Hannity asked if he planned to raise the issue during the debate, Stephanopoulos sounded a bit vague--almost as if he was unaware of the controversy. When Hannity listed key elements of the Obama-Ayers relationship, Stephanopoulos replied, "I'm taking notes."
And apparently he was. The ABC news anchor raised the same points in his question for Mr. Obama during the debate. From The New York Times transcript:
MR. STEPHANOPOULOS: Senator, if you get the nomination, you'll have to -- (applause) -- (inaudible).
I want to give Senator Clinton a chance to respond, but first a follow-up on this issue, the general theme of patriotism in your relationships. A gentleman named William Ayers, he was part of the Weather Underground in the 1970s. They bombed the Pentagon, the Capitol and other buildings. He's never apologized for that. And in fact, on 9/11 he was quoted in The New York Times saying, "I don't regret setting bombs; I feel we didn't do enough."
An early organizing meeting for your state senate campaign was held at his house, and your campaign has said you are friendly. Can you explain that relationship for the voters, and explain to Democrats why it won't be a problem?
Not surprisingly, Obama's response was less-than-satisfactory:
SEN. OBAMA: George, but this is an example of what I'm talking about.
This is a guy who lives in my neighborhood, who's a professor of English in Chicago, who I know and who I have not received some official endorsement from. He's not somebody who I exchange ideas from on a regular basis.
And the notion that somehow as a consequence of me knowing somebody who engaged in detestable acts 40 years ago when I was 8 years old, somehow reflects on me and my values, doesn't make much sense, George.
The fact is, is that I'm also friendly with Tom Coburn, one of the most conservative Republicans in the United States Senate, who during his campaign once said that it might be appropriate to apply the death penalty to those who carried out abortions.
Do I need to apologize for Mr. Coburn's statements? Because I certainly don't agree with those either.
So this kind of game, in which anybody who I know, regardless of how flimsy the relationship is, is somehow -- somehow their ideas could be attributed to me -- I think the American people are smarter than that. They're not going to suggest somehow that that is reflective of my views, because it obviously isn't.
Regrettably, Stephanopoulos didn't follow-up on Obama's comparison of Bill Ayers to a conservative Republican Senator. Mr. Ayers is an admitted domestic terrorist, whose past actions have resulted in the loss of American lives. Senator Coburn, on the other hand, has never actually proposed the death penalty for abortion providers. Contrary to Obama's assertions, there's a world of difference between Senator Coburn and Bill Ayers. But his oily answer did provide an opening for Hillary Clinton:
SEN. CLINTON: Well, I think that is a fair general statement, but I also believe that Senator Obama served on a board with Mr. Ayers for a period of time, the Woods Foundation, which was a paid directorship position.
And if I'm not mistaken, that relationship with Mr. Ayers on this board continued after 9/11 and after his reported comments, which were deeply hurtful to people in New York, and I would hope to every American, because they were published on 9/11 and he said that he was just sorry they hadn't done more. And what they did was set bombs and in some instances people died. So it is -- you know, I think it is, again, an issue that people will be asking about. And I have no doubt -- I know Senator Obama's a good man and I respect him greatly but I think that this is an issue that certainly the Republicans will be raising.
To be fair, Mr. Obama did point out that Senator Clinton has her own "terrorist" problem. When Bill Clinton was in the White House, the pardoned two other members of the Weather Underground, and 17 members of the Puerto Rican terrorist group, the FALN.
On his question about Israel, Stephanopoulos was clearly inspired by Krauthammer's column, which called for the United States to issue a "Holocaust Declaration" in support of the Jewish State. Under that policy, the American nuclear umbrella would be extended to cover that nation; any nuclear attack against Israel would be treated as a nuclear strike on the U.S., and bring a devastating response from our strategic forces.
As with the Ayers query, Obama tried to waffle and equivocate:
MR. STEPHANOPOULOS: Senator Obama, let's stay in the region. Iran continues to pursue a nuclear option. Those weapons, if they got them, would probably pose the greatest threat to Israel. During the Cold War, it was the United States policy to extend deterrence to our NATO allies. An attack on Great Britain would be treated as if it were an attack on the United States. Should it be U.S. policy now to treat an Iranian attack on Israel as if it were an attack on the United States?
SEN. OBAMA: Well, our first step should be to keep nuclear weapons out of the hands of the Iranians, and that has to be one of our top priorities. And I will make it one of our top priorities when I'm president of the United States.
I have said I will do whatever is required to prevent the Iranians from obtaining nuclear weapons. I believe that that includes direct talks with the Iranians where we are laying out very clearly for them, here are the issues that we find unacceptable, not only development of nuclear weapons but also funding terrorist organizations like Hamas and Hezbollah, as well as their anti-Israel rhetoric and threats towards Israel. I believe that we can offer them carrots and sticks, but we've got to directly engage and make absolutely clear to them what our posture is.
Now, my belief is that they should also know that I will take no options off the table when it comes to preventing them from using nuclear weapons or obtaining nuclear weapons, and that would include any threats directed at Israel or any of our allies in the region.
MR. STEPHANOPOULOS: So you would extend our deterrent to Israel?
SENATOR OBAMA: As I've said before, I think it is very important that Iran understands that an attack on Israel is an attack on our strongest ally in the region, one that we -- one whose security we consider paramount, and that -- that would be an act of aggression that we -- that I would -- that I would consider an attack that is unacceptable, and the United States would take appropriate action.
Hillary Clinton was quick to pounce:
SENATOR CLINTON: Well, in fact, George, I think that we should be looking to create an umbrella of deterrence that goes much further than just Israel. Of course I would make it clear to the Iranians that an attack on Israel would incur massive retaliation from the United States, but I would do the same with other countries in the region.
Readers will note that there was no follow-up question on Clinton's response. While her answer was aimed at getting votes from key electoral groups, there are problems with extending the nuclear deterrent to Israel, as we observed in a recent post. At best, the so-called "Holocaust Declaration" may be premature, given Israel's own, robust nuclear deterrent and existing missile defense systems.
Still, Mr. Stephanopoulos deserves credit for posing some reasonably tough questions that conservatives have been asking for weeks. For his effort, the former Clinton White House advisor is being excoriated by left-wing blogger, who are calling the debate an "ABC hit job." And, with the Democratic candidates still refusing to debate on Fox News, these may be the last answers we hear on the Ayers issue and the nuclear umbrella for some time.
Wednesday, April 16, 2008
Iran's Big Fly-By
At least 140 aircraft will participate in the event, part of the annual "Army Day" celebration. The Iranian Air Force commander, General Muhammad Alavi, told local reporters that the parade will "reveal the power of the Iranian armed forces to defend their homeland."
Among the aircraft expected for the fly-by are MiG-29 Fulcrum fighters; F-14 Tomcats; "Sukhois" (a likely reference to SU-24 Fencer strike fighters or SU-25 Frogfoot ground attack aircraft); aerial tankers, "interceptors" and Boeing 707 and 747 passenger planes.
Air parades aren't normally an intelligence boon, unless they are used to reveal a new plane, helicopter or other airborne system. Still, it will be interesting to tally the number of various airframes appearing in the event. Mission-capable rates for much of the Iran's air fleet--including its fighter squadrons--are rather low. It would be remarkable if tomorrow's fly-by includes more than 3-4 F-14s, a similar number of SU-24s, and slightly larger formations of MiG-29s and SU-25s.
In fact, Iran's most capable fighters (in terms of sorties flown and generation rates) are their elderly, U.S.-built F-4 Phantoms and F-5 Freedom Fighters. Tehran is believed to have 20-30 operational F-4s and 40-50 F-5s, which form the backbone of their interceptor and ground support squadrons.
Obviously, not all of those planes will appear in the Army Day parade. And that begs and obvious question: how will Tehran generate 140 aircraft for the fly-by? With a generous helping of helicopters, special mission aircraft (say, Iran's two SIGINT platforms) and civilian jetliners, Iran can probably reach the desired total. But there isn't much room for error on the military side, given the relatively small number of combat-capable jets and lackluster mission-ready rates.
In terms of quality, Thursday's event will also be lacking. The newest planes slated for display are the Russian-built fighters--and some of them were confiscated from Iraq almost 20 years ago. Iran may use the event to showcase its new "Lightning" fighter, but that aircraft is nothing more than a rebuilt, 40-year-old F-5 with slightly improved avionics and a second vertical stabilizer.
To beef up the parade, Iran could try a tactic that worked for the Soviet Union, in the early days of the Cold War. As part of a massive military parade through Red Square, large formations of Soviet bombers flew overhead. The number of bombers that appeared was much higher than U.S. estimates, touching off a minor panic in the intelligence community. How did the Russians build so many bombers without being detected?
The answer, as we later learned, was simple. Russia didn't have that many bombers. Instead, the same aircraft kept circling, repeatedly passing over Red Square. No one bother to check the fuselage numbers (or other similarities), so the ruse went undetected for years.
Will Iran try the same trick in Thursday's parade? Today, the deception would be easy to spot, but that might not be enough to deter Tehran. After all, tomorrow's air event is aimed largely at Iran's neighbors and the western press, groups that will be less discriminating in analyzing the fly-by.
The Most Dangerous Job in Iraq, Redux

The EOD Memorial at Eglin AFB, Florida. Fifteen EOD technicians died in the line of duty last year (EOD Memorial Committee photo)
The tragic death of Technical Sergeant Capra reminds us of the risks they take willingly, on our behalf. It takes a special breed of hero to make the long walk downrange to an IED or unexploded round, keenly aware that you may never return. Sergeant Capra made that walk many times. His fellow technicians are doing the same thing today, in places like Iraq and Afghanistan.
If you're traveling through the Florida panhandle, take a few minutes and visit the EOD Memorial at Eglin. And by all means, consider a donation to the EOD Memorial Committee, based in Niceville, Florida. Their scholarship fund awards more than $60,000 a year to deserving students, the sons and daughters of current and former EOD technicians.
Patches Flies On

"Patches" on the ramp at a base in Southwest Asia. Forty years after the C-130's hair-raising flight into Khe Sahn, the airlifter still flies combat missions (USAF photo).
Tuesday, April 15, 2008
One Step Closer
In a 35-minute proceeding at Bolling AFB in Washington, D.C., Army Chief Trial Judge Colonel Stephen Henley scheduled pre-trial motions for 23 June, with the court-martial to follow on 21 July, though that latter date is tentative.
Murphy, who served as Commander of the Air Force Legal Operational Agency until his dismissal in November 2006, is facing nine counts of conduct unbecoming an officer; one count of failing to obey a general order, and three counts of larceny of more than $500.
Colonel Murphy was removed from his post after it was revealed that he had practiced as a military attorney for more than two decades without a law license. When Murphy joined the Air Force in 1983, his law license had been suspended in Texas, for failing to file an appeal for a civilian client.
Texas followed with disbarment in 1984, after learning that Murphy had applied for a law license in Louisiana--without telling that state of his past disciplinary problems. Murphy was subsequently disbarred in Louisiana in 1985. By that time, he had been a military attorney for almost two years.
Air Force prosecutors charge that Murphy never informed his superiors of his disbarment. Military regulations require that judge advocate generals (JAGs) and defense counsels be licensed to practice law in at least one state, territory, or the District of Columbia.
If convicted on all counts, Colonel Murphy could receive a 41-year prison sentence, be dismissed from service and lose his military pension.
According to Air Force Times, Murphy appeared glum during Monday's proceedings. He did not enter a plea or express his preference for a jury or bench trial. Judge Henley granted requests from the Colonel's defense team to delay those decisions until after preliminary motions are heard.
The Murphy court-martial is a bit unusual in that an Army judge has been appointed to hear the case. The Air Force's Judge Advocate General, Major General Jack Rives, asked the Army to provide a military judge for the court-martial, given the defendant's former position as a high-ranking Air Force lawyer.
In his previous assignment at the Legal Operations Agency--and an earlier tour as Commander of the Air Force JAG school--Colonel Murphy influenced the training and careers of many of the service's attorneys and military judges. That raised concerns about whether Murphy could receive a fair trial from an Air Force judge.
The wheels of military justice have moved slowly in the Murphy case; by the time its goes to court in July, more than 18 months will have elapsed since the Colonel was relieved of his position. That delay suggests a dogged, methodical approach by military prosecutors, who have systematically built their case against Murphy.
And for good reason. the Air Force JAG corps has been under a microscope since the forced retirement of then-Judge Advocate General, Major General Thomas Fiscus, in 2005. Fiscus was sacked after it was learned that he had a history of inappropriate relationships with female subordinates. While Fiscus was retired as a Colonel--a reduction of two pay grades--the Air Force was widely criticized for the "lenient" punishment he received.
Hoping to avoid similar accusations in the Murphy case, the Air Force appears to be taking a hard-line approach. Nine of the original charges against the former JAG have been dismissed, but Murphy still faces multiple counts of "conduct unbecoming," stemming from his repeated acceptance of new positions that required a valid law license. The "failure to obey" charge is also based on Murphy's violation of credentialing requirements for military lawyers.
Larceny counts filed against Murphy are unrelated to the licensing issue. Prosecutors say they are based on other incidents, uncovered during the lengthy investigation. Military law experts believe the charges stem from government-paid trips that Murphy took to legal conferences and other professional seminars. Participants at those events were supposed to have a law license, something Murphy did not possess.
As we've noted in past posts about the Murphy saga, we are not attorneys and we'll gladly defer to experts in military law. But, judging from the pace of the investigation and preliminary legal proceedings, we'd say the chances for a plea bargain are virtually nil. This case will clearly be decided in court.
Murphy and his legal defense team face an uphill battle when the court-martial convenes this summer. Keeping the Colonel out of Leavenworth will take something approaching a legal miracle. Avoiding jail time and preserving Murphy's pension will require the skills of a Daniel Webster or Clarence Darrow. But don't hold your breath. While Colonel Murphy has some skilled lawyers in his corner, the Air Force legal system--the same one that Murphy helped administer for more than 20 years--has a conviction rate approaching 98%.
A Sex Scandal Done Right
And, right on cue, there's another immensely entertaining tale of lust and debauchery that is currently rocking the U.K. This one involves, in no particular order, Formula One racing; a one-man/five-hooker orgy; whips, chains, various participants parading in Nazi garb, and of course, the obligatory You Tube video.
Oh, did we mention that the man at the center of this controversy is the son of Britain's most famous facist, Sir Oswald Mosley--and his mother remained "terribly fond" of Hitler until the end of her life? Or that their son had a spot of tea for his "ladies" after the Nazi sex-fest was over?
Anne-Elisabeth Moutet of the BBC provides the rest of the sordid details, in the current edition of the Weekly Standard.
According to Ms. Moutet, the man who arranged this little tryst, Formula One racing chief executive Max Mosley, paid a little under $5000 for his fantasy. Eliot Spitzer ought to demand a refund.
And to think that NASCAR fans were shocked, shocked! when Jeff Gordon divorced his first wife.
***
ADDENDUM: Today's News of the World has the latest bizarre turn in the Mosley scandal. Turns out that Max could be excommunicated from racing by the Pope! Turns out that the Vatican is a member of the the governing body of Formula One, the FIA, which will decide Mosley's fate.
H/T: No Damn Blog.
Monday, April 14, 2008
We Couldn't Make This Stuff Up

Your tax dollars at work. An "anti-perching" device at Langley AFB, VA, designed to keep birds away from the installation--and its F-22 stealth fighters. The Air Force spent $16 million on birdstrike-related damages in 2007 (USAF photo).
The latest adversary for the Air Force's F-22 Raptor stealth fighter? No, it's not a new Flanker variant, the Chinese J-10, or even budget-cutters in Congress and the Pentagon.
No, the F-22 is facing an even more sinister threat--free-falling clams.
From TSgt Russell Wicke of the Air Combat Command Public Affairs Office:
Free-falling clams dropped by in-flight birds are regular air threats to the F-22 as gulls drop fist-sized mollusks on the Langley Air Force Base runway to break open the shell-fish appetizer.
The birds' shelling device just happens to be a convenient launch pad for the F-22. Although the gulls remove half their mess -- slurping up tender meat from the runway -- they leave behind hard, brittle sea shells for an F-22 to suck up through its engine intake that can cause severe damage.
Although the Air Force is wildlife friendly, Lt. Col. Lawrence Spinetta, the 1st Fighter Wing Safety Office chief, isn't willing to let a $10.2 million jet engine go to the birds -- or the clams.
Langley AFB officials run an aggressive flight-safety program to mitigate the Bird and Wildlife Aircraft Strike Hazard, also called BASH.
"BASH is particularly important for Raptors because they are so expensive," Colonel Spinetta said. "If we lose one aircraft, it costs the Air Force and taxpayers $135 million.
[snip]
Federal Aviation Administration officials claimed birds cost the civil aviation industry about $600 million per year. Air Force officials coughed up approximately $16 million in 2007 from bird-strike damages. Only a few types of birds account for the majority of the damage. Certain species in particular do more than peck at the Air Force wallet.
For example, the turkey vulture alone accounts for nearly 800 strikes and more than $51 million in Air Force flying history, said Dan Sullivan, the Air Force BASH deputy chief and wildlife scientist. It ranks No. 1 in Air Force bird strikes.However, the most expensive bird is the American white pelican. In only 18 strikes, this bird accounts for more than $257 million in damages. Mr. Sullivan said this cost is attributed to the size and weight of the bird -- a whopping 20 pounds -- compared to an average 5 pounds for the turkey vulture.
"The black vulture and turkey vulture are the greatest threat to Air Force aircraft overall because they are somewhat large and soar at high altitudes -- about 3,000 feet," Mr. Sullivan said. "During the day as the air warms up, they ride a rising thermal draft. Their high altitude makes them hard to detect from the ground."
These vultures, among other avian species, are increasing in population because of U.S. conservation efforts, he said.
[snip]
Almost nothing can be done, short term, to avoid high-altitude strikes. But the Langley AFB BASH team is heading up a project to track the migration of the osprey, the fifth most-dangerous bird species to aircraft, Colonel Spinetta said. There are more than 72 osprey nests within a 20-mile radius of Langley AFB.
To mitigate the growing threat, officials from the 1st FW, NASA and USDA came up with a unique way to track the osprey.
"Captured birds were fitted with Global Positioning Systems-capable transmitters ... (that) transmit the altitude, speed and direction of travel of each bird every two hours," Colonel Spinetta said in an editorial for the Flight Safety Magazine. "As a result, Langley AFB has been able to pinpoint nests and focus its reduction, suppression and prevention efforts to eliminate many osprey hazards."
The nests are usually relocated to safer areas by USDA members.
Other more traditional techniques for eliminating hazards involve harassing birds on the airfield, Mr. Olexa said. The most common tool is simply a combination of pyrotechnics and artificial bird distress calls, called bioacoustics. This, he said, is especially useful for birds like gulls that drop their food on the runway. Other long-term techniques take a bit more forethought, called habitat manipulation.
"The trick is to make the airfield less attractive to wildlife," Mr. Sullivan said. One way is by planting certain grass species that cause an upset stomach to geese. Another example is to avoid planting fruit/nut producing trees.
The Langley AFB BASH team also covered tall airfield objects with spiny metal strips, or cone shaped devices, to deny perching to birds.
One technique, which is considered a last resort, is called depredation, or lethal action. But Mr. Sullivan said the purpose of lethal action is to remind other birds there's an actual threat, not to terminate the flock.
The article doesn't say how much it cost to outfit those Ospreys (the bird, not the plane) with those GPS units. Not to mention the added expense of planting less tasty grass species, and placing all those perch-denial devices.
No one denies that bird strikes are a significant aviation hazard. Twelve years ago, a collison with a goose resulted in the loss of an E-3 AWACS (and 24 crew members) at Elmendorf AFB, Alaska. But, some of the "solutions" in place at Langley are bound to be more costly than other measures, say a covey of security policemen (or hunters) armed with shotguns.
Seagull season, anyone?
H/T: David Axe at the Danger Room.
About That Forecast
Yes, there was a significant outbreak of severe weather across the South and Midwest last week. But it failed to equal the events of 34 years ago (Thank God), not to mention more recent outbreaks of tornadoes and severe thunderstorms
How did the forecasters get it wrong? Accu-Weather meteorologist Jesse Farrell offers a few thoughts:
My personal opinion in regards to the over-hyping of this outbreak (which I participated in) is that the meteorologists (everywhere) were paying too much attention to matching the overall weather pattern to 1974, and not spending enough time looking at the many wonderful Severe Weather Indices from the Forecast Models. As I noted in my blog on Tuesday and Thursday, these never looked very impressive, or when they did, they were in different geographical locations. Why didn't I promote that fact more? Honestly, since I'm so out-of-the-loop these days in regards to what our forecasters are thinking, I assumed there was something obvious I was missing, and I didn't want to be the guy who said "this outbreak is going to be lame" and we get hundreds of tornado reports.
For the record, the National Weather Service's Storm Prediction Center (SPC) reported a total of 57 tornadoes over a four-day period last week (9-12 April). By comparison, there were 149 tornadoes during the Super Outbreak of 1974, which occurred over a 24-hour period.
The Holocaust Declaration
Invoking memories of John F. Kennedy's famous words during the Cuban Missile Crisis, Dr. Krauthammer suggests that President Bush offer a similar policy statement on Iran. Call it the Holocaust Declaration:
"It shall be the policy of this nation to regard any nuclear attack upon Israel by Iran, or originating in Iran, as an attack by Iran on the United States, requiring a full retaliatory response upon Iran."
The statement, he continues, should be followed with a simple explanation: "As a beacon of tolerance and as a leader of the free world, the United States will not permit a second Holocaust to be perpetuated upon the Jewish people."
Krauthammer believes the declaration is needed for rather obvious reasons. First, contrary to the "findings" of the recent National Intelligence Estimate, Tehran has not abandoned its efforts to build nuclear weapons. Just last week, Iran announced that it is installing 6,000 additional centrifuges at the Natanz enrichment facility, and suggested that the new centrifuges have an expanded production capability. That will allow Iranian scientists to increase their output of enriched uranium, which can be used in nuclear weapons--once the required purity level is attained.
As the columnist notes, the world yawned in reaction to Iran's latest admission. Making matters worse, diplomatic efforts to halt Iran's bomb program have been colossal failures:
The latest round of U.N. Security Council sanctions, which took a year to achieve, is comically weak. It represents the end of the sanctions road.
At home, the president's efforts to stop Iran's nuclear program were irreparably undermined by November's National Intelligence Estimate, whose "Moderate Confidence" that Iran has not restarted nuclear weaponization--the least important of the three elements of any nuclear program--has promoted the illusion that Iran has given up the pursuit of nuclear weapons. Yet uranium enrichment, the most difficult step, proceeds apace, as does development of nuclear-capable ballistic missiles.
The president is out of options. He is going to hand over to his successor an Iran on the verge of going nuclear. This will deeply destabilize the Middle East, threaten the moderate Arabs with Iranian hegemony and leave Israel on hair-trigger alert.
Given those realities, Dr. Krauthammer believes the "Holocaust Declaration" is our best hope for deterring Iran. While acknowledging that Tehran is hardly a rational state actor, he thinks the threat of a massive U.S. nuclear strike, in response to a nuclear attack against Israel, will be enough to make the mullahs think twice. Moreover, he writes, the policy holds little risk for the United States, since Iran's crude nuclear devices and delivery systems pose no threat to the CONUS--although they could target U.S. military forces in the Middle East and portions of Europe.
While we can't disagree with his assessment of Iran's nuclear program, or the failure of current deterrence efforts, the proposed Holocaust Declaration is premature, at best. Attempting to provide a military rationale for the policy, the Post columnist claims that Israel's nuclear arsenal could be easily wiped out, eliminating its deterrent--and counter-strike--value. We disagree.
Fact is, Israel has the largest nuclear arsenal in the Middle East, totaling more than 200 tactical and strategic warheads. For argument's sake, let's say an Iranian attack achieves operational surprise, and the initial strike eliminates one-third of Israel's nuclear arsenal. That still leaves Tel Aviv with almost 150 warheads for a retaliatory attack. We should also note that Israeli weapons are much more powerful than those initially available to Iran. In other words, Israel's nukes carry a far bigger punch and they would inflict far more damage and casualties--against more targets--than Iran's first strike.
Additionally, Tehran faces the daunting challenge of pinpointing and accurately hitting Israel's nuclear arsenal. True, Iranian intelligence knows the location of Israeli fighter bases and its primary missile installation, but their ability to track dispersed aircraft and missiles is severely limited. That task is further complicated by the IDF's extraordinary skills at military denial and deception. Virtually every successful campaign waged by Israeli forces has been accompanied by a detailed deception campaign, giving the IDF strategic or tactical surprise. Given that history, it's quite possible that Israel would beat Iran to the punch (with its own preemptive strike) or inflict a devastating counter-strike, utilizing aircraft and missiles that survived Tehran's initial onslaught.
Krauthammer also ignores the fact that Israel has steadily expanded its nuclear options, acquiring delivery platforms that are more survivable. In the late 1990s, the Israeli Navy bought three modern diesel-electric submarines from a German shipyard, and hired another German firm to modernize its existing Gal-class boats.
All of these vessels are equipped with torpedo tubes as large as 650 mm, raising speculation that Israel will deploy--or has deployed--nuclear-tipped cruise missiles on its submarines. Former officials with the State Department and the Pentagon reported in 2002 that Israel had conducted successful cruise-missile tests in the Indian Ocean. Operating from the Red Sea, the Arabian Sea or even the Persian Gulf, Israeli submarines offer another platform for a nuclear strike against Iran.
It's also worth remembering that Israel is the only country in the world with a layered, over-lapping missile defense system, deployed primarily against the Iranian threat. Currently, Israeli Arrow II and Patriot batteries offer a high degree of protection against Tehran's only viable nuclear delivery option--medium-range ballistic missiles.
While no system is 100% effective, Israel's existing missile defenses have the ability to knock down most of the Iranian missiles aimed at Israel. Defending against terrorist rockets fired from Lebanon or the Gaza Strip is a different matter; however, those systems lack the payload capacity to carry a nuclear warhead.
By comparison, Iran has no missile defenses. Any nuclear warhead delivered by an Israeli Jericho II ballistic missile or a cruise missile would almost certainly reach its target. Israeli Air Force (IAF) jets, flying long-range strike missions against Iran, also have a high probability of reaching their destinations.
At this juncture, Israel has more than enough nuclear options--and defensive capabilities--to theoretically deter an Iranian attack. We emphasize that words for the same reasons outlined by Charles Krauthammer. Tehran is not always given to rational deeds. Some Iranian leaders, anxiously awaiting the return of the 12th Imam, would probably welcome a nuclear exchange with Israel, believing it would hasten their desired Armageddon.
As for the United States, there are clear geopolitical problems that would come with a Holocaust Declaration. At a minimum, the White House would be pressed to extend similar coverage to other allies in the Middle East, raising the question of who should--and should not--be covered by our nuclear umbrella.
We will give Dr. Krauthammer credit for broaching an extremely sensitive, yet important, subject. If Iran is left unchecked, the declaration he advocates may one day become necessary. By the end of the next decade, Tehran will possess a significant nuclear arsenal and large numbers of ballistic missiles with more advanced decoys and counter-measures. That will increase the likelihood of Iranian missiles penetrating Israeli defenses, inflicting far greater casualties.
Facing that threat--not to mention possible Iranian nuclear "proxies" in Syria and Lebanon--Israel will be forced to expand its own nuclear arsenal and spend even more on missile and civil defense programs. With American taxpayers picking up much of that tab, a future U.S. president may find it necessary, perhaps imperative, to extend our special relationship with Israel.
Still, the odds of that happening are distant. With Iran on an apparent collision course with its adversaries, the issue of its nuclear program (and how to deal with it) will be resolved sooner, rather than later.
***
On a related note, the U.K. Independent reports that the U.S. and Iran have been engaged in "back channel" talks on its nuclear program for the past five years. Turns out that the U.S. negotiators are academics and former diplomats. The paper reports (correctly) that such talks have been useful in the past, we rather doubt this effort will bear fruit. Not only have these discussions been going on for a long time, but the initiative seems fatally flawed. The talks apparently focus on the idea of letting Iran enrich uranium on its own soil, while promising not to divert nuclear fuel for military purposes. Tehran's track record in keeping such promises is second only to North Korea.
Saturday, April 12, 2008
Idiot of the Week

Italian artist Giuseppina Pasqualino de Marineo (left) and a companion, on their "Brides for Peace" tour through the Middle East. Ms. De Marineo's performance-cum-crusade ended tragically in Turkey, where she was raped and murdered (BBC photo)
Normally, that way of thinking typically results in more government programs, new activist groups, various media crusades and the latest crop of leftist politicians. But sometimes, it can get you killed.
Consider the case of 33-year-old Giuseppina Pasqualino di Marineo, an Italian performance artist. Ms. Di Marineo and a friend came up with a novel idea for promoting peace in the Middle East. Wearing bridal gowns, the planned to hitchhike through the region. The so-called "Brides for Peace" tour would carry them from Turkey, through Lebanon, the "occupied" territories and on to Jerusalem. Exactly how this would promote peace was never fully explained, but Di Marineo and her friend launched their expedition a few weeks ago, filled with high hopes.
After arriving in Istanbul, Di Marineo and her fellow artist took different paths, with plans to link up in Beirut. You can probably guess what happened next. From the AHN news agency:
Di Marineo's naked and decomposing body was found in bushes near the city of Gebze, which is located on the eastern edges of Istanbul, on Friday night, according to Di Marineo's Web site.
Turkish police reported that they have arrested Murat Karatas in connection with the killing, who later confessed that he first raped and then killed her.
"Her travels were for an artistic performance and to give a message of peace and of trust, but not everyone deserves trust," another sister, Maria, told the Italian news agency, Ansa, according to BBC News report.
Di Marineo's project was meant to bring peace to the war-torn areas like Mediterranean and the Balkans as they dressed as brides and travel by hitch-hiking.
That's right, peace in the Middle East can be achieved by a couple of western "artists," hitch-hiking through the region, and dressed in bridal gowns. There's no word on whether Di Marineo's companion plans to continue her journey. We can only imagine what kind of reception she'll receive from the local Hizballah and Hamas delegations in places like Beirut or the West Bank.
While the passing of Ms. Di Marineo is regrettable, we're a bit amazed by the tone of media coverage. The accounts we've read depict her journey as some sort of noble mission, rather than the fool's errand it was. Somewhere along the line, you'd think that a clear-thinking adult would have told the "artist" that her mission was an invitation to disaster, one that unfolded on that road near Istanbul.
But, we're guessing that most of Di Marineo's friends share her values and world-view. Now, they're left to mourn the results of her horribly misguided "artistic project."
For her final performance, the late artist is a slam-dunk winner of "Idiot of the Week" honors, and an early nominee for the 2008 Darwin Awards.
Shooting for the Stars--Or Something Else
Experts interviewed by the Jerusalem Post said the rocket shown in Monday’s launch appeared to be an “ordinary” Shahab-3 medium-range ballistic missile (MRBM). The first Iranian missile capable of striking targets in Israel, the Shahab-3 is only capable of lifting extremely small payloads—30 kilograms or less—into space. Even small research satellites typically weigh hundreds of kilos.
Tehran launched its first space booster last February; according to press and intelligence reports, the vehicle reached the edge of space, but did not go into orbit. Iranian officials did not disclose the altitude reached by the rocket launched yesterday, or the status of its payload.
[snip]
Indeed, there are no indications that Iran has solved the technological hurdles necessary for building (and placing) geosynchronous communications satellites in orbit, or developed low earth orbit (LEO) systems that could be used for cell traffic or paging. Beyond that, there’s the question of cost: even in a country the size of Iran, it would be cheaper—and faster—to lay more fiber optic cable and erect more cell towers, rather than build a fleet of LEO satellites.
On the other hand, a space program is the perfect cover for expanded missile development efforts. Along with the Shahab-3, Tehran is also working on longer-range systems, including the Shahab-4. While ostensibly described as a “space booster,” the Shahab-4 has military applications, and could deliver chemical, biological or nuclear warheads against targets throughout the Middle East.
And, by “mixing and matching” various missile stages, Iran could (sometime during the next decade) fashion a crude ICBM, capable of reaching the United States. It’s the same approach that has been used by North Korea, which is providing extensive technical support to the Iranian missile program. But unlike Pyongyang, Iran is not operating on a shoe-string budget. Flush with oil revenue, they can acquire more advanced Russian and Chinese technology, improving the reliability and accuracy of their missiles.
This is not to say that Tehran doesn’t have an interest in space. Iran has already launched a crude imaging satellite and hopes to orbit improved versions in the near future. Those platforms will give the Iranians the capability to obtain targeting data on potential adversaries, including U.S. military forces in the Persian Gulf. Access to that information will lessen Tehran’s reliance on commercial satellites and platforms owned by other nations.
The timing of the Iranian ”space push” also illustrates their wider goals. As we’ve noted in the past, development of a nuclear weapons capability is actually a three-track process. Along with the weapon, aspiring nuclear powers must also have access to delivery systems and overhead targeting data. Feverish efforts in missile and satellite development offer one more indication that Iran’s nuclear program is far from dead; in reality, it’s continuing apace, and will yield a fully-developed capability in the coming years.
Two months later, other experts have reached the same conclusion. In his weekly "Inside the Ring," column, defense reporter Bill Gertz of the Washington Times notes a recent a recent assessment from Jane's Intelligence Review:
The authoritative British magazine provided an analysis of the launch, based on commercial satellite photographs and Iranian TV footage. The analysis reveals that, contrary to Iranian government claims, the new missile is a single-stage version of the Shahab-3 medium-range missile.
"Tehran has said the February 4th test was the first step toward launching a satellite," the Jane's analysis stated in the April edition. "However, the test appears to be part of the ongoing Shahab program, with no significant improvement in Iran's ballistic missile, and therefore space, program."
"Nonetheless, the Kavoshgar launch site or space center suggests that Iran is seeking to significantly develop its satellite, and hence ballistic missile, program by following a similar path to North Korea's Taepodong-1 missile program.
A defense department official also told Mr. Gertz that the missile tested in February appears to be a Shahab-3.
The confirmation comes as little surprise to analysts who have followed Tehran's ballistic missile program. While Iran is interested in developing a space launch capability, those plans are secondary to its medium and long-range missile efforts.
With newer Shahab-3 variants (and the BM-25, purchased from North Korea last year), the Iranians can now target the entire Middle East and portions of southern Europe. On its current path, Tehran could have a crude ICBM by the middle of the next decade--tipped with a nuclear warhead.
Friday, April 11, 2008
Today's Reading Assignment
And that's a pity, as Mr. Auslin notes. President Lee is exactly the kind of leader the United States has been looking for in Seoul, after a decade of appeasement policies toward the north. Too bad he won't get the support he needs from a lame duck administration that has grown increasingly short-sighted toward Korea.
An important and timely read, from The Weekly Standard.
Buh-Bye Katie
Thursday, The Wall Street Journal claimed that the network was in talks to end Couric's tenure as anchor of the Evening News, with a departure sometime after next year's presidential inaguration. The NYT article suggests a much earlier resignation, based on a reported meeting between Couric, her agent and two senior CBS executives: Les Mooves, the president of the network, and Sean McManus, head of the news division.
With its flagship newscast mired in last place, CBS has apparently judged the Couric experiment a dismal failure, and is preparing to, once again, reshape the Evening News. Recent Nielsen ratings confirm the scope of the network's problems. With Ms. Couric in the anchor chair, the Evening News drew an average of only 5.9 million viewers during the last week of March, compared to 8.3 million for NBC Nightly News with Brian Williams, and 8.0 million for ABC's World News with Charles Gibson. CBS's evening newscast has been in last place for more than 12 years.
You don't need to be a broadcast executive to understand that lower ratings and declining audience figures translate into decreased ad revenue and diminished profits. But poor ratings for the Couric broadcast have produced a ripple effect at CBS, and among its affiliated stations. With fewer people watching, the Evening News generates a smaller lead-in audience for newscasts on local stations, including those owned by the network. That has produced howls from the affiliates, who rely on local news as a major source of advertising revenue.
And, if that's not enough, CBS is more reliant on revenue from its broadcast division that other media companies. Without a cable news partner or major cable presence, the so-called Tiffany network is more susceptible to slumps in the broadcast advertising market--or its own poor programming decisions.
Then, there's the matter of CBS's local stations, which have been less profitable that rival outlets owned by NBC and ABC. Dominating prime-time programming for years, CBS made only fitful efforts to improve its local stations, while ABC built its owned-and-operated outlets into cash cows. Today, ABC-owned stations dominate the local ratings in New York, Chicago, Los Angeles, Houston and Philadelphia, and its San Francisco outlet (KGO-TV) is near the top of that market. As you might expect, high ratings for local news programs translate into bigger audiences for network evening newscasts.
Which brings us back to Ms. Couric. Having worked in the broadcasting salt mine, I can assure you the decision to part ways with the star anchor was not made lightly. In addition to audience ratings, CBS has conducted its own, extensive market research into its news product and anchor. Those studies have reached the same conclusion as viewers; Katie Couric is a horrible fit for the Evening News, and CBS will face further audience erosion if she remains in the anchor chair. At $15 million a year, the network can no longer justify her hefty salary.
While Couric's representatives and the network negotiate her departure, the scramble to succeed the Perky One is already underway. But securing a replacment may not be that easy. CBS made a run at NBC's Tim Russert before signing Couric, but there's no indication he would be more receptive this time around; NBC's main anchor, Mr. Williams, isn't going anywhere, and the same holds true for ABC's Charlie Gibson. Among the cable anchors, Shepard Smith of Fox News Channel recently signed a new deal that pays him as much as his broadcast network peers. Scratch him off the list.
Among anchors with current or former ties to CBS, the pickings are equally slim. CNN's John Roberts left CBS in 2006 because he was not named to replace Dan Rather. 60 Minutes correspondent Scott Pelley was also a contender two years ago, but network executives decided he didn't have enough charisma for the Evening News. ABC's Diane Sawyer might be interested, but on the heels of the Couric disaster, it's unlikely that CBS will put another woman in the nightly anchor slot. CBS morning host Harry Smith is another candidate, but his show has always been a ratings laggard, and it's doubtful he would be more successful on the evening broadcast.
In fact, the most likely successor to Couric is the "interim" anchor who preceded her, Bob Schieffer. After announcing plans to retire this year, Schieffer revealed a few weeks ago that his departure was being delayed, but no one connected that decision to possible changes at the Evening News. Now, with Katie heading toward the door, it's almost a sure bet that Bob Schieffer is the once-and-future anchor of the CBS Evening News.