Wednesday, February 14, 2007

Mookie Hits the Road

Citing defense sources, various media outlets are reporting that radical Iraqi Shia leader Moqtada al Sadar has fled to neighboring Iran, taking key members of his Mahdi Army with him.

Senior military leaders told ABC News that al Sadr left Baghdad two or three weeks ago, and is now living in Tehran, where he has family. Senior leaders in his militia reportedly accompanied him to Iran. Their departure coincided with the start of a U.S. troop build-up in Iraq, and promises by the country's Prime Minister that al Sadr (and other militia leaders) would no longer be protected by the government.

With American troops preparing to enter--and remain--in al Sadr's Baghdad stronghold, the cleric was apparently concerned that he might become a target. One U.S. official told ABC's Martha Raddatz "He is scared he will get a JDAM (satellite-guided bomb) dropped on his house."

The sudden departure of Al Sadr and his top commanders leaves the Mahdi Army with a potential leadership vaccum in the coming months, as more U.S. troops enter Iraq. Al Sadr's minions still have the resources to carry out their daily ration of bombings and assassinations, but their ability to formulate long-term strategy may be impaired by Al Sadr's absence. Moreover, members of his militia will hardly be inspired by their leader's sudden decampment, and they may be less inclined to do Mookie's bidding while he's in exile.

Almost everyone agrees that Al Sadr's stay in Iran will be limited. Over the past three years, Al Sadr has become one of Tehran's most effective proxies in Iraq, and the Iranian government does not want his organization to wither. In fact, there's some speculation that Mookie's sudden move to Tehran may actually be some sort of "recall" by his Iranian sponsors, designed to get him out of harm's way (on a temporary basis), and facilitate discussions on future terrorist strategies in Iraq.

In the interim, it might be helpful if the Iraqi government did something that might dissuade Sadr from returning to the country, such as resurrecting the murder charges against him that were "postponed" back in 2004. But I'm guessing that Prime Minister al-Malaki doesn't have the political capital--or willpower--to pull off that sort of move. There is some consolation, however, in the knowledge that Sadrist influence in the Iraqi government may wane a bit with their leader out of the country, and give al-Malaki a bit more room to maneuver. Psychologically, Al Sadr's sudden departure may offer an inadvertent boost to the troop surge and on-going security operations in Baghdad. Taking up residence in Iran, Al Sadr seems to be expressing more confidence in the surge--and its prospects for success--than the Democrats in the House and Senate.

Tuesday, February 13, 2007

Kicking the Can?

At first blush, it's tempting to describe the tentative deal between the U.S. and North Korea as an exercise in "kicking the can down the road." Pyongyang has agreed, in principle, to close down and seal its main reactor within 60 days, in exchange for 50,000 tons of fuel oil, as a first step in abandoning its nuclear weapons and research program. There were similar provisions in the ill-fated, 1994 "Agreed To Framework," which (essentially) paved the way for a covert North Korean program, which yielded the primitive nuclear device tested last fall. In light of the DPRK's demonstrated willingness to break deals and negotiate in bad faith, there is a tendency to view the accord with a great deal of suspicion, wondering how long it will last, and even speculate about when Pyongyang will make new demands that could derail the entire process.

Today's Washington Post has a good summary of the agreement--and the hurdles that remain in the implementation process. Disabling the reactor represents the next phase in a largely undefined phase of "denuclearization," which also includes discussions on plutonium fuel reserves and other efforts that will be abandoned under the accord. In return, the North will receive additional energy, humanitarian and economic assistance, up to the equivalent of 1 million tons of heavy fuel oil. The U.S. has also agreed to discuss the possible normalization of relations with the DPRK--a longstanding goal of Pyongyang--and resolve a dispute over North Korean money laundering through a Macau bank.

U.S. negotiators view the tentative agreement as a "down payment" on a nuclear-free Korean peninsula, and improved relations between North Korea and its neighbors. Of course, the devil is always in the details, and the success of this agreement will (ultimately) hinge on the continued engagement of the "other" participants in the Six Party talks--particularly Japan, China and Russia. Beijing and Moscow still have considerable leverage with Kim Jong-il's regime, and their willingness to support limited sanctions against the north probably convinced Pyongyang that it was time to cut a deal. But will the Russians and Chinese be willing to continue to exert pressure on Pyongyang as the implementation process moves along? That's the $64,000 question, and a cynic would argue that the DPRK's long-time allies may lean more on the U.S. to uphold its end of the bargain, while granting North Korea more leeway in its "denuclearization" efforts.

Then, there's the question of what exactly happens to Pyongyang's accumulated nuclear technology and expertise. The "limits" of the North's nuclear efforts have never been fully documented, and the U.S. has only vague ideas about the number of scientists and engineers employed in various weapons and research programs sponsored by the DPRK. With North Korea supposedly getting out of the nuke business, what's to keep Kim Jong-il's scientists from taking their talents to Iran, North Korea, Venezuela, or other countries with nuclear ambitions.

Dealing with that possibilty represents a major challenge of the denuclearization process. To help prevent the spread of nuclear technology, is the U.S. prepared to propose some sort of extension of the Nunn-Lugar Act, which could provide stipends for unemployed North Korean nuclear engineers and researchers? Nunn-Lugar has often been hailed as an example of effective counter-proliferation efforts, but it has not prevented Russian--and even North Korean--nuclear specialists from traveling to places like Iran. Moreover, with the DPRK in dire economic straits, nuclear technology represents one of its few "viable" exports. Given that reality, it's difficult to imagine Pyongyang simply shuttering the program, and rejecting a source of badly-needed hard currency. Making matters worse, one could argue that the proliferation "horse is already out of the barn," given the apparent ties between North Korea's nuclear programs and those of other rogue states. These relationships also give Pyongyang of continuing their weapons development efforts "offshore," and outside the framework of the peninsula agreement.

Today's nuclear deal is certainly better than no deal at all, but it's easy to be pessimistic about the accord's long-term prospects for survival and implementation. North Korea got much of what it wanted in the announced deal (and so did the U.S.), but there's genuine concern that Pyongyang will--eventually--decide it wants even more, and demand concessions that Washington and Seoul simply can't grant. Or, the DPRK may simply revert to its behavior of the mid-1990s, making public efforts to "observe" the agreement, while continuing a covert nuclear program. That's why the next round of the process, when North Korea discusses the scope of its nuclear efforts, will be so important. Pyongyang has rarely been forthcoming about anything, and you can expect them to hem and haw when the U.S. submits tough questions about its nuclear activities. And don't be surprised if the "answers" to those questions come with an additional "price."

***

One final thought: liberal pundits are already drawing parallels between today's agreement and the Agreed To framework of 1994. But their analysis (typically) ignores a critical point. The 1994 deal was the result of diplomatic "free lancing" by that old dictator and terrorist coddler, Jimmy Carter. Acting on his own, Mr. Carter went to Pyongyang and proposed a deal, which the Clinton Administration elected to go along with. The Bush Administration--wisely--kept Carter out of the loop on this one, electing instead to mount a regional diplomatic approach. Hopefully, the new deal will prove more successful--and verifiable--than the 1994 accord, which proved to be a disaster, both diplomatically and militarily. We'll soon see if Mr. Bush (and his negotiators) have created a mechanism for solving the North Korean nuclear problem, or simply given the can another kick.

But the Carter deal served a useful purpose for Mr. Clinton, who was anxious to get North Korea off the table, and focus on domestic issues, like welfare reform and school uniforms. By accepting a flawed accord in 1994, Clinton kicked the North Korean can down the road, forcing his successor to deal with the problem.

Monday, February 12, 2007

Missile Defense Works (Again)

According to Israeli public television, the Jewish State has carried out another successful test of its Arrow II ballistic missile defense systems. As recounted in this report by AFP, the nightime test replicated the intercept of an Iranian Shahab-3 medium-range missile, which is capable of hitting Israeli territory. Israeli TV said the test was designed to "send a message" to Tehran.

Operational details of the test are sketchy, and Israel's Ministry of Defense is expected to release a statement later today. Israeli media indicates that the Arrow II successfully intercepted a missile launched from a high-altitude aircraft. The interceptor missile was launched from Palmahim AB, south of Tel Aviv.

If those accounts are accurate, the test sounds identical to those conducted earlier with the Arrow II. During those evaluations, an Israeli Air Force F-15 launched a Black Sparrow missile over the eastern Mediterranean. The missile flies a parabolic orbit, designed to mimic a Shahab-3 targeting Israel. Guided by a Green Pine battle management radar, the Arrow II intercepted the target missile, and blasted it from the sky.

The U.S. has provided extensive funding and engineering support for the Arrow II program, and key elements of that technology have been incorporated into our own BMD efforts. The Arrow II is one of the most advanced missile defense systems in the world, and the only one that is fully operational. While the most recent test was clearly aimed at Tehran, there's a message for the U.S. as well: missile defense works, and we need to press ahead with our efforts in that arena, and battle critics like Michigan Senator Carl Levin, who (given the chance) would completely gut our program, and leave us unprotected.

The Smoking Gun

Thanks to the estimable Bill Roggio for his excellent summary of yesterday's U.S. military press conference, which detailed Iranian support for terrorists in Iraq. During that event, American experts provided convincing evidence that Tehran is actively aiding the insurgents with arms, weapons expertise, and training. According to coalition spokesman Maj Gen William Caldwell:

"Iran is involved in supplying explosively formed projectiles or EFPs and other material," such as "explosive charges, booby traps, mortar shells of different calibers and remote controls" to detonate IEDs to "multiple" insurgent groups." Those in attendance "were shown fragments of what the defense official said were Iranian-made weapons, including one part of an EFP and tail fins from 81-mm and 60-mm mortars." "More than 120 US and coalition troops have been killed by these things, and 620 wounded. There was a significant increase in there use over the past six months," he said.

And, General Caldwell left no doubt as to the level of complicity in Iran:

"We assess that these activities are coming from the senior levels of the Iranian government," the defense official said, 'noting that the Al-Qods brigade reports to Iran's supreme leader, the Ayatollah Ali Khamanei.' "Iranian weapons were experimented in South Lebanon by Hezbollah and were later developed," for deployment into Iraq.

The Irbil raid in early January netted the most significant evidence, as well as a senior member of the Iranian Qods Force. Six Iranians were detained in Irbil, including Mohsin Chizari, the operational commander of the Qods Force, the Iranian Revolutionary Guards Corps specialized force that is equivalent to U.S. Special Forces. During the Irbil raid, "the Iranians were caught trying to flush documents down the toilet," and "bags of their hair were found... indicating they had tried to change their appearance." Chizari was "apprehended after slipping back into Iraq after a 10-month absence." Earlier it was reported Chizari was detained in the Baghdad raid, and subsequently released.

Now, compare General Caldwell's comments with those of Rhode Island Senator Jack Reed, who discussed the Iranian connection on "Fox News Sunday." Despite the compelling evidence presented in Baghdad--which suggests involvement at the highest levels of Iran's government--Reed actually suggested that "rogue elements" in Tehran might be running the support operation.

"I think the evidence is confused. There are certainly indications, as Mr. Gates pointed out this week, that these explosive foreign projectiles seem to be coming from Iran. They've been used.

The question is is this a deliberate policy of the Iranian government at the highest levels. Is it rogue elements within the government? And then the other question is to what extent are there countervailing signals that the Iranians actually are trying to — not control, but not to further raise the stakes in Iraq.

So it's a very complicated situation."

Not being a member of the "World's Greatest Deliberative Body," my world view is considerably less nuanced than Senator Reed's. But, what we've found in Iraq seems clear enough; let's do a quick review: Forensic evidence of Iranian-produced weapons and shaped explosive devices being used against our troops. The arrest--in Iraq--of six members of Iran's Revolutionary Guards Qods Force, which reports directly to that nation's supreme leader. One of the six arrested in Irbil was a senior operational commander of the Qods force. And, that raid also netted documents that further highlighted the Iranian connection, including reports to the Supreme Leader.

As for the purpose behind these operations in Iraq, that too, seems abundantly clear: kill Americans and force the U.S. to withdraw, setting the stage for Iran to dominate the scene once we're gone. That's not the sort of operation runs by a few rogue elements in the Revolutionary Guards; it's a policy with clear ties to the highest levels of Tehran's government. Even Senator Reed, a West Point graduate, ought to be able to figure that one out.

Saturday, February 10, 2007

Voyeur Nation

Back in the 1950s, the patron saint of broadcast journalism, Edward R. Murrow, hosted a weekly interview show on CBS called Person to Person. Both the tone and content of the program were surprisingly light for a Murrow vehicle; while the show devoted some episodes to world leaders and politicians, there were more than a few celebrity interviews, conducted live in their homes. Many of Murrow's colleagues thought the program was beneath his talents; in their minds, it was difficult to reconcile the crusading journalist who took on Joe McCarthy with the man who chatted with Liz Taylor or Sammy Davis, Jr. on a Friday evening.

Murrow frequently claimed that he did Person to Person to help his writers "pick up a little change." In reality, Ed Murrow owned the show, and he made a lot of green from those celebrity interviews. When he left CBS, Murrow sold the rights to the show back to the network for $1 million. But the criticism never ended, nor did Murrow's willingness to do the program as long as he remained on the network's payroll. According to writer and CBS historian Gary Paul Gates, when a fellow journalist accused him of "whoring," Murrow smiled and replied, "Yes, but look at all those voyeurs."

Obviously, Ed Murrow never met Anna Nicole Smith, but he clearly understood the culture that produces such a celebrity. And, had Ms. Smith achieved her peculiar "stardom" 50 years earlier, I'm sure that Murrow would have tried to secure an interview, to satisfy his audience of voyeurs. True, he would shudder at some of the breathless coverage of Smith's life (and recent death) from the tabloids and infotainment shows, but Murrow realized that celebrities still attract an audience, and celebrity train wrecks bring in even more viewers. Even in the staid 1950s, Person to Person generated a far larger audience than his more serious journalistic enterprises, such as See It Now, and the documentaries he produced for CBS Reports.

So, in some respects, our fascination with the celebrity culture (and their personal problems) is something that existed long before Entertainment Tonight and People magazine. But, on the other hand, you've got to wonder if--or when--our voyeur nation will finally get its fill of the salacious and the titillating. Many Americans will claim that they lost interest in Ms. Smith and her tawdry life about the time her first Playboy issue was ready for the trash can. That may be true (to some extent), but there were still enough spectators to keep Smith's "career" going for almost two decades. Millions of Americans are only vaguely aware that Iran is actively pursuing nuclear weapons (which may prompt U.S. military action) but they can recite the "highlights" of Smith's life, chapter and verse.

In a certain, perverse way, Anna Nicole deserves partial credit for that. Extending one's 15 minutes of fame by a factor of 1000 (with no obvious talent beyond physical appearance) is no mean feat, particularly in a society that disposes of passe celebrities like so many used Kleenex. In fact, cynics might argue that Ms. Smith's untimely demise will actually prove an adroit career move, securing her place in the pop culture pantheon. As evidenced by James Dean, Marilyn Monroe, Jayne Mansfield and Elvis, American loves a celebrity who drops dead in the prime of life, ensuring continuing interest--and income--for decades to come. Fifty years after his death, Dean's estate still earns thousands of dollars a year in licensing and royalty fees, and Elvis became far more popular after his passing than in the latter stages of his actual career. The value of the Presley brand increased a hundred-fold in the decades after he died.

Consequently, Ms. Smith's post-mortem stay in the limelight is not only the latest example of our collective fascination with the morbid, but it also speaks volumes about a culture cast adrift from its moral moorings. Not too many years ago (perhaps in Ed Murrow's day), the excessive and outlandish behavior of celebrities would spark certain interest, but it would also produce outrage and condemnation that would shame the offender and likely, end their career. The life of Anna Nicole Smith proves once more that anything goes in our culture, and anyone who speaks out against such "alternative lifestyles" are nothing more than cultural cretins. And sadly, Ms. Smith's conduct was almost tame by some standards; alcohol and drug abuse, shameless gold-digging, an out-of-wedlock birth. Compared to the icons of gangsta rap and certain segments of the film community, Anna Nicole Smith was almost a candidate for the Young Republicans.

Which brings us back to a society that was fascinated by Anna Nicole Smith and allowed her to earn an income and fame that far exceeded her modest talents. On one hand, it supposedly proves that anyone can achieve the American dream. On the other, it also demonstrates that Ed Murrow's voyeur nation is more prone to peep than ever before.

No New Tactics

That's the assessment of Army Vice Chief of Staff, General Richard Cody, in response to recent U.S. helicopter losses in Iraq. General Cody, a former attack helicopter pilot, is currently on a swing through the Middle East, and spoke about the recent spate of shoot-downs--and what they mean--with the AP:

"I see no change in trends" on the part of the insurgent's targeting efforts, "and I see no capability gaps" on the part of U.S. forces.

Cody said all U.S. helicopters in Iraq recently received upgraded defensive systems to protect them against known threats like anti-aircraft missiles, although he acknowledged that helicopters on combat missions face inherent dangers, including small arms fire if they fly low to avoid being targeted by missiles.

"We've been studying the heck out of this thing," he said, referring to the crashes, which began in January with the shootdown of a Black Hawk helicopter in which all 12 U.S. soldiers were killed. Later in January two Apache attack helicopters were shot down, apparently by small arms fire, killing two in each.

General Cody also emphasized the need for aviators to remain vigilant and less predictable in their operations.

"As soon as you get predictable, as soon as you get a little bit complacent, either the enemy will get you or this terrain will get you," he said, referring to the rugged, often mountainous landscape in which they fly

Unfortunately, AP military writer Robert Burns apparently didn't press General Cody on the rationale behind that recent "upgrade" in helicopter defensive systems. There are a number of reasons for such an upgrade, ranging from long-planned system improvements, to changes in the threat environment. Judging from Cody's comments, it sounds like the upgrade was in the works before the recent rash of shoot-downs, although revised IR jammer and/or flare dispenser programs can be quickly added to self-defense systems in response to increased threats.

Mr. Burns might have also asked about missile launch trends in Iraq, although Cody's remarks suggest that there hasn't been a major change in that area, either. Historically, the number of MANPAD launches against our aircraft in Iraq has been fairly consistent over the past three years, based on the limited data that I've seen. General Cody's observations suggest that the number of launches are within "normal" parameters, but the enemy is enjoying more success as of late. And, those meetings with aviators in Iraq and Afghanistan suggest that there is concern about complacency on the part of crews.

***

One final observation: Burns concludes his story with cursory data on cumulative helicopter losses in Iraq and Afghanistan, noting that the U.S. has lost "a little over 100 aircraft" since the start of combat operations, a period in which American crews have logged more than 1.4 million flying hours. That's a loss rate of roughly 7-8 choppers per 100,000 flying hours, the typical benchmark on which losses are calculated. But Burns doesn't differentiate between helicopters shot down by hostile fire, and those lost due to other causes (weather, mechanical problems, crew error). And that's an important distinction; let's assume that only half of the helicopters were downed due to enemy fire; that drops the loss rate in that category to 3 or 4 per 100,000 flying hours. That's about what you would expect in combat operations, even in relatively "permissive" environments like Iraq and Afghanistan.

Friday, February 09, 2007

Pelosi's Deceit

Having hit a little public relations "turbulence" over her request for a Boeing 757 for flights between California and Washington D.C., Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi is back-pedalling a bit. Ms. Pelosi said earlier today that she would be "happy" to fly commercial, if the military can't provide an aircraft that can make the trip non-stop.

Not surprisingly, Ms. Pelosi (and her supporters) are being less-than-honest about what the Air Force has offered, and what that aircraft is capable of doing. To support her transcontinental travels, the service proposed that the new speaker use the same aircraft has her predecessor, Illinois Republican Denny Hastert. After 9-11, when the speaker began using military jets on a routine basis, Hastert made the trip between D.C. and his home district on a C-37A, the Air Force's VIP transit version of a Gulfstream V. Note the C-37's range: 5500 nautical miles, more than sufficent for a cross-country jaunt, even when required fuel "minimums" and distances to divert fields are factored in. The larger C-32/Boeing 757 that Pelosi wants has the same range, and its cruising speed is slower than the Gulfstream. Of course, the C-32 carries more passengers (and is more expensive to operate), but it looks a hell of a lot more impressive when it arrives at an airport, carrying Speaker Pelosi and her entourage.

BTW, you've got to love Pelosi's argument that stopping for fuel somehow reduces the "security" of the flight. Readers will note that the MSM (and House Democrats) conveniently ignore the fact that these refueling stops would occur at Air Force bases--or other DoD installations--that are even more secure than commercial airports. On the other hand, most military personnel are Republicans, and the prospective refueling bases are in Red States, so maybe that explains Nancy's apparent paranoia over refueling.

***

If Pelosi is really concerned about staying aloft, here's a solution for her problem. Rather than opting for a mere C-32, why not upgrade all the way and request a C-17 transport. True, it has far fewer creature comforts, but it can carry far more people; heck, the Air Force could even slide a "comfort pallet" into the cargo hold, complete with airline-style seats and a lavatory that smells like it hasn't been "downloaded" in a while. The Air Force could even toss in some MREs or box lunches (a.ka. box "nasties"), served by a grouchy loadmaster. Heck, with a C-17, Pelosi could ferry the entire California Congressional delegation back home for the weekend. The accomodations wouldn't be very posh, but hey, the C-17 can be refueled in-flight, eliminating the need for those time-consuming stopovers in Jesusland.

The MANPAD Problem

Thanks to Powerline for spotting this Ralph Peters column on the recent spate of helicopter losses in Iraq. Peters is correct in identifying the apparent strategy behind the terrorists' renewed interest--and apparent success--in engaging our transport, surveillance and attack helicopters. As he notes, if the terrorists are successful in limiting our mobility through the skies of Iraq, that will force our troops to rely even more on road transportation, setting the stage for more IED attacks and additional casualties.

We've been covering the issue of helicopter losses in Iraq for some time; our latest post on the subject can be found here. At this point, any analysis of the subject must be accompanied by an important caveat: officially, the Pentagon isn't saying much about the losses, other than to acknowledge that at least four of the helicopters were brought down by hostile fire. Insurgents also claim to have shot down a fifth chopper (a Marine Corps CH-46 Sea Knight) earlier this week, but the military indicates that mechanical problems were responsible for that crash. Additional details would be helpful in determining whether the terrorists are using both anti-aircraft artillery (AAA) and man-portable SAMs, or if most of the losses were caused by missiles.

The distinction is important. Losses to both AAA and MANPADs would indicate that insurgent weaponry hasn't changed much--particularly if the missile losses can be traced to systems that have been in Iraq for years, such as the Russian-built SA-7/14/16. We have extensive knowledge of those systems, their performance and how to defeat them. If the enemy used older MANPADs to bring most of these choppers down, it would suggest that (a) their training and tactics have improved; (b) we've become a little too complacent and predictable in our operations, or (c) a combination of those factors. Even older MANPADs and basic air defense weapons (such as heavy machine guns) can be more effective if you've got some idea of when helicopters are likely to pass overhead, and optimum ways for attacking them.

On the other hand, there is also the chance that terrorists have, in fact, acquired more advanced MANPADs from external sources. The most likely missile in that category would be the Russian-made SA-18, which has on-board Infrared counter-Countermeasures (IRCCM), giving it some ability to resist/defeat an aircraft's defensive suite. This improvement is achieved (primarily) by "cooling" the missile seeker, making it more sensitive, and capable of engaging targets from all aspects. By comparison, early-generation MANPADS (SA-7/14; U.S-built REDEYE) do not have cooled seekers, and can only engage targets from their rear, where the IR signature is strongest.

While the SA-18 would represent an improvement in the terrorists' air defense arsenal, the system is not a world-beater by any standard. As with the older, Russian MANPADS, we have extensive knowledge of the SA-18 and methods for countering it. If the SA-18 is suspected, crews will receive additional intel information on potential employment sites and adversary tactics; at the same time, defensive gear on the choppers will also be tweaked, allowing IR jammers and flare dispensers to operate in the most effective manner.

Are we facing an upgraded MANPAD threat in Iraq? At this point, I can't say, based on information that is publicly available. If the terrorists had acquired an advanced, shoulder-fired SAM, we would also expect them to employ it against slow-moving transport aircraft that operate in the skies over Iraq. Downing a C-130 or C-17 could, potentially, generate far more casualties, yet there have been no reports of increased MANPAD launches around major air hubs. Aggressive patrolling around Baghdad International Airport (BIAP), Balad and other key airfields is probably one reason. Yet despite that, we would still expect the terrorists to take a potshot at a transport or even an airliner, if they had a "new" weapon that was more likely to bring down a large aircraft. The absence of such attempts (based on what we know) tends to lessen the possibility of a "new" weapon, although that possibility certainly can't be ruled out.

In reading various reports on the recent helicopter losses, I did find this interesting tidbit: some media outlets indicate that the Defense Secretary Robert Gates and JCS Chairman General Peter Pace are reviewing procedures in the wake of these incidents. That's a bit puzzling, since reviewing (and approving) changes in tactics, techniques and procedures is something normally done far down the chain. However, Secretary Gates and General Pace would be interested in the introduction of advanced weapons systems by the enemy, particularly if the hardware can be traced to a particular supplier (read: Iran).

My prediction? In the tit-for-tat world of tactics and counter-tactics, we'll know what caused these losses very soon (if we don't already) and make the necessary operational adjustments. That's the nature of warfare.

Wednesday, February 07, 2007

Paging Dr. Phil

In the wake of astronaut Lisa Nowak's bizzare meltdown on Monday, various psychoanalysts (professional and amateur) are trying to make sense of it all, offering their own explanations as to what went wrong.

We should point out that no psychological condition has been officially ascribed to Captain Nowak. She has been released on bail from a Florida jail, and returned to Houston, where she will (presumably) receive help with the issues that prompted her to drive 900 miles to Orlando, confront an apparent romantic rival, and allegedly spray that woman with pepper spray.

At least one comment on this blog suggested that Captain Nowak's behavior may have been triggered by a bi-polar disorder. I've known a few individuals who suffer from that condition, and they are capable of outlandish--even destructive--actions if they haven't been diagnosed, or don't take prescribed medication.

Among the mental health professionals, one Maryland psychiatrist, Dr. Jack Vaeth, is suggesting that Nowak's outburst may be the result of another condition, narcissistic personality disorder, typically found among exceptionally high achievers.

Thwarted in their ambitions or conquests, people accustomed to success, adulation and entitlement can slide into a rage or a disastrous series of decisions that can bring down their careers. His favorite example? Bill Clinton.

Vaeth teaches and practices at the Sheppard Pratt Health System hospital in Towson. He also has a private practice in Annapolis. He has no special knowledge of Nowak's case but plenty of experience with self-centered achievers.

"Certain professions are made up of narcissistic personalities, although maybe not disordered ones," Vaeth said. They include doctors, lawyers and CEOs, "high achievers who ... feel 'I have an edge on the world, and society rewards me for it.'

"They were always the teacher's pet, their parents' favorite child," he said, "so of course they're going to want to continue that. ... Everything they undertake, they're winners. And even when they lose, they learn to win better next time."

In time, they come to believe that they're entitled, invincible, "able to exploit others without being called to the mat for it."

When he lectures about the syndrome, he points to the former president.

"The whole time in the Oval Office with Monica [Lewinsky], you and I would be scared to death [of getting caught]," Vaeth said. "He's thinking, 'They'll never believe I did it.'"

When a narcissist's achievement or conquest is thwarted, he or she can fall into a rage, Vaeth said. "When the right buttons are pushed, they explode."

So far, everyone's favorite TV shrink, Dr. Phil, hasn't weighed in Captain Nowak's predicament, but you've got to believe that he's got an episode in the works. As for me, I'm waiting for Shrinkwrapped's take on the whole thing.

***

As for how this scenario plays out, I spoke with some friends who work as criminal defense lawyers and public relations experts. The lawyers expect some sort of deal to be worked out, with Nowak entering a guilty plea to lesser charges; they think the attempted murder charge is a stretch, and quite frankly, I agree. Given her record of achievement and complete lack of past criminal behavior, they expect Mowak might be sentenced to house arrest, followed by a long period of supervised probation.

On the PR end, the spin doctors project that Nowak will quietly announce her "resignation" from the astronaut corps 3-4 months down the road, after undergoing treatment for her problems. At the same time, Captain Nowak will also request retirement from the Navy; she already has 26 years of service, including her time at the Naval Academy, more than enough for retirement.

But that creates something of a quandry for the Navy. Currently, the service is letting the civilian justice system take its course. The Navy still has the option of filing additional charges against Nowak under the UCMJ, but it's unclear when--or if--that might happen. When Captain Nowak leaves NASA, she will again become the "property" of the USN, and there will be pressure to punish her for breaches of military conduct and discipline.

However, I don't think the Navy wants to prolong the embarassment over the Nowak incident, and would prefer to let the matter die as quickly as possible. Toward that end, I can see the service offering Nowak non-judical punishment (probably an Article 15) for her deeds, and retirement as a Commander (O-5), one grade below her present rank. On the other hand, Nowak might be allowed to leave the service at her present grade (Captain)--and without punishment--if her behavior can be attributed to a mental health disorder that went undiagnosed and untreated.

Missile Test

Iran has successfully tested its recently-acquired TOR-M1 air defense system, according to state-run television and the stenographers at AFP.

I'll lump AFP into that less-than-distinguished school of journalism, because their story on the event has at least one major error. Check out their "file photo" of the TOR-M1 (NATO designator: SA-15/GAUNTLET) that accompanied the article. There's a little problem with that photograph --it isn't an SA-15. It's a picture of an older SA-11/GADFLY surface-to-air missile system, which is not in the Iranian inventory. Here's a picture of an SA-15; you'll note the "lack" of external missiles on that system. That's because the missiles are stored internally, for additional protection against the elements and potential battle damage. BTW, my apologies for not posting the photos directly in the blog, but the "picture" feature of Blogger isn't working, at least on my computer.

There is a noticeable difference in performance between the SA-15 and the SA-11. Both are modern SAM systems, but the GADFLY has roughly three to four times the range of the SA-15. The GAUNTLET is designed (primarily) for short-range and point defense of high value targets, while the SA-11 was originally envisioned as a replacement for the SA-6/GAINFUL, optimized for defense of armored formations and troops on the move.

I'm also a little skeptical about the "successful" test results, until I have a chance to watch the video. Watching video of missile tests, you'll typically see a shot of the missile leaving the launcher, with a quick cut to the "close-up" of the missile destroying the target. The SA-15 is more than capable of engaging a variety of targets (including tactical aircraft and cruise missiles), but given Iran's recent history of exaggerated claims, it's not beyond them to play a little "cut and paste" with the test video. I'll withhold final judgment until I see the tape.

Additionally, here are a couple of additional points to watch for in test videos. More often than not, the target drone is flying straight and level, with no maneuvering--in other words, a cooperative target that's much easier to hit. And, there's no mention of jamming or electronic countermeasures (ECM) in the test. The SA-15 has excellent capabilities in countering ECM, but (once again), it makes for an easier shot if the target isn't trying to jam your radar. Finally, there's the question of how much Russian support was required for the test; extensive contractor support would indicate potentially low proficiency levels among Iranian crews, decreasing their chances for success in combat.

Make no mistake; acquisition of the SA-15 represents a major upgrade for Iran's air defense system. But crew competency and operational proficiency have yet to be fully demonstrated. Any assessment of Tehran's capabilities with the new system must wait for more observation--and analysis--of SA-15 training and operational patterns.

Air Pelosi

Today's Washington Times has an interesting article that's attracting virtually no attention in the MSM. Seems that Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi is leaning on the Air Force to make a C-32 transport available for trips between Washington and her district in San Francisco. Times' reporter Rowan Scarborough has learned that one of Pelosi's key Congressional allies--Pennsylvania Representative John Murtha--has been urging the Air Force to meet Pelosi's demands, and (according to one source) accused the military of sexism by not immediately approving the speaker's request.

Pelosi's demand for a large jet is simply outrageous, but a little background is in order. After 9-11, then-speaker Dennis Hastert of Illinois was given access to a smaller, commuter-style jet, for travels between his district and Washington. Use of the aircraft was provided due to "security concerns," according to the Times. Since the Democrats took control of Congress last month, members of Pelosi's staff and her House allies have been pressuring the Pentagon to make the C-32 available for the speaker's travels. The C-32 is the military equivalent of a Boeing 757-200, with seating for up to 45 people (in very comfortable conditions), a crew of 16, and a range of more than 5,000 miles. Pelosi reportedly plans to use the aircraft to transport herself, family members, Congressional staffers and other Congressmen, between the nation's capitol and the West Coast. Needless to say, the cost of operating the C-32 is higher than the business jets used by Hastert after 9-11, or the cost of commercial travel, which was utilized by previous speakers.

Congressional Republicans have criticized the new speaker's request for the larger aircraft; one of them even dubbed the jet "Pelosi One." But the GOP is not without sin in this matter; in fact, the entire jet controversy is nicely described by one anonmyous DoD official, who says that Congress views the Air Force VIP jet fleet (based mostly at Andrews AFB), as "their Hertz rent-a-car." Members of the House and Senate frequently use the aircraft for "fact-finding" trips to various locales around the globe, on the taxpayers' dime. The Air Force is only too happy to comply; meeting Congressional transporation requests is a good way to ensure funding for more important, service-related programs. I'm told the VIP/special airlift program is run out of the office of the Air Force's Vice Chief of Staff, offering some indication of the importance attached to those Congressional missions. Air Force and House staffers are currently working to "reconcile" the Pelosi request, with existing laws governing the use of VIP aircraft. That tells me the Speaker is going to get her C-32, one way or the other.

Ms. Pelosi may be third in line for succession to the presidency, but she doesn't need a Boeing 757 airframe for trips to California. A much smaller jet--say, a C-21--should more than suffice. If additional staffers, family members and Democratic operatives need to make the trip, then let the speaker dig into her well-lined pockets and buy them an airline ticket. Not only is Ms. Pelosi a multi-millionaire; as a member of Congress, she also receives a transportation allowance each year, intended specifically for that sort of travel.

If House Republicans are genuinely interested in reforming the VIP airlift program, they might consider capping the number of aircraft in the fleet, and better accountability on how those jets are used. For every "legitimate" mission flown by these aircraft, there are too many flights that are nothing more than a waste of resources. But I'm guessing that the GOP minority won't pursue this matter very far. Assuming that Pelosi's request for the C-32 is approved--and the Republicans retake the House in 2008 or 2010--the next GOP speaker would probably like to have the aircraft as his private jet, too.

Tuesday, February 06, 2007

The Wrong Stuff

In his classic book The Right Stuff, Tom Wolfe noted the contradiction between the carefully crafted public image that NASA maintained for its astronauts, and their private behavior. As Mr. Wolfe reminds us, the "original seven" Mercury astronauts were all products of a military aviation culture that popularized "Flying & Drinking & Drinking & Driving," and tolerated other indiscretions as well. Wolfe never exactly "named names" in The Right Stuff but he did report that some young ladies around Cape Canaveral in the early 1960s staged a contest, to see how many astronauts they could sleep with. Wolfe also observed that among the "Mercury Seven," only John Glenn came close to meeting the "Boy Scout" image that NASA cultivated for its astronauts.

Ah, for the Good Old Days.

As you've probably heard, NASA has a new (ahem) image problem on its hands, and it has nothing to do with O-Rings, incompetent administrators, or chunks of insulation foam that doom a shuttle's reentry. This latest crisis stems from yesterday's arrest of astronaut Lisa Nowak, who faces charges of attempted kidnapping, battery, vehicle battery, and other counts. Nowak, who is also a Navy Captain (O-6), drove 900 miles from Houston to Orlando, to confront Colleen Shipman, an Air Force Captain who is her apparent rival for the affections of another shuttle astronaut, Navy Commander William Oefelein.

The AP has all the sordid details. Nowak reportedly wore astronaut diapers on her drive to Orlando, so she wouldn't have to stop to urinate. After confronting Shipman at the airport, Nowak reportedly sprayed her rival with pepper spray, then discarded various weapons (a steel mallet, a 4-inch knife and a BB gun) as she tried to escape. Police found a love letter from Nowak to Oefelein in her car, along with e-mails between the two astronauts. Nowak is currently being held without bond, and faces a court hearing today in Orlando.

NASA's reaction to all of this has been predictable.

NASA spokesman James Hartsfield in Houston said that, as of Monday, Nowak's status with the astronaut corps remained unchanged.

"What will happen beyond that, I will not speculate," he said.

Hartsfield said he couldn't recall the last time an astronaut was arrested and said there were no rules against fraternizing among astronauts.

But Mr. Hartsfield is ignoring a couple of important facts. First of all, each of the individuals involved in this triangle are military members, and subject to the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ). Fraternization is a punishable offense under the UCMJ, given that Nowak outranks Commander Oefelein, and both apparently fall in the same chain of command (the NASA Astronaut Office). However, the good Commander isn't necessarily off the hook, either. If he willingly participated in a relationship with Nowak--and that hasn't been confirmed--then, he's guilty of fraternization as well. Captain Nowak, on the other hand, could also face adultery charges, since she's married and has three children. At the time of her arrest, Nowak described her connection with Oefelein as "more than a working relationship, but less than a romantic relationship." Somewhere, Bill Clinton must be smiling.

Oefelein may also have problems regarding his relationship with Captain Shipman. True, both are apparently single, but there has long been an informal, "one up/one down" rule on dating in the ranks; in other words, you don't date someone more than one grade above you or below you to avoid any appearance of fraternization. As a Navy Commander, Oefelein is two grades higher than Air Force Captain (O-3) Shipman. Oefelein might also face discipline if we find out that Shipman is also assigned to NASA, and in his chain of command. At this point, it may be accurate to potray Oefelein as a victim in this mess, but I'm not exactly impressed with his judgment. Oefelein may be an ace shuttle pilot, but it also looks like he's trying channel Jack Nicholson's character in Terms of Endearment.

To a casual observer, the Nowak debacle suggests a couple of things: First, NASA's vaunted psychological screening procedures must be slipping. It's difficult to fathom that someone with obvious mental problems could make the cut for the astronaut corps and actually fly a mission without her defects being exposed. Astronaut training and mission preparation are rigorous and demanding by design, aimed at weeding out anyone who can't handle extreme pressure. As a taxpayer, it's a little disturbing to think that someone who went off the deep end over a failed office romance was apparently flying on the space shuttle.

The second lesson from all of this is that the military needs to tighten control of personnel assigned to the astronaut office in Houston. Historically, the military has adopted a "hands off" approach to officers who qualify as astronauts. While serving with NASA, military personnel retain their rank, pay and other benefits, but supervision is minimal, and enforcement of standards is apparently lax. For example, take a look at Nowak's "official" astronaut photograph, linked here.
I'm hardly an expert on Navy dress and appearance standards, but Capt Nowak's "spacesuit" hairstyle does not appear to be within military limits. If you're willing to compromise on one of the fundamental standards for any member of the armed services (dress and appearance), you're probably willing to cut corners in other areas, too.

One final thought:
reading her NASA bio
, it looks like Captain Nowak was one of the Navy's "golden girls;" an Academy grad; two post-graduate engineering degrees, and selection for the service's test pilot school. She has over 1,500 flying hours in high-performance aircraft--low for an officer of her rank--and you'll also note another thing missing from her resume: deployment time and combat experience. Nowak's resume suggests a woman who's been aiming for the shuttle since the day she entered Annapolis, with the support and encouragement of Navy leadership. And, her lack of service "with the fleet" has not hampered her advancement. Nowak apparently made Captain on time, and might have had a shot at Rear Admiral, had she not made that fateful, diaper-clad drive from Houston to Orlando.

Regarding Nowak's lack of operational experience, it is true that women were barred from combat duty during the early stages of her career, but those restrictions were gone by the mid-1990s. Instead of putting her test flight and electronic combat experience to work in the fleet, Captain Nowak signed on with NASA. She's been in Houston for more than a decade, working her way up the astronaut chain, and (apparently) lookin' for a little orbital love on the side. Meanwhile, other naval aviators have been flying the line, flying combat missions in the Balkans and the Middle East, and pulling those six month carrier deployments to the Persian Gulf and the western Pacific. It would be interesting to know what the "real" naval aviators think of Nowak, her gilded areer, and the discredit she's bringing upon NASA and the Navy.

***

Addendum: As a public service, we're organizing a "Lisa Nowak/Love Among the Stars" contest, allowing you to predict the ultimate disposition of this case. Submit your answers to the questions below to icspook86@hotmail.com. Readers with the most accurate answer in each category will receive their choice of a NASA baseball cap or coffee mug. Entry deadline is 31 March 2007. Enter as many times as you'd like. In the event of a tie, the winner will be determined by the date/time of the earliest e-mail received. Good luck, and here are your questions:

1) Predict the month/year when the Navy will announce Captain Nowak's "retirement" from the service, and the rank/pay grade she will retire at.


2) Predict the month/year when Mr. Nowak will file for divorce.


3) Predict the month/year when Captain Nowak will enter rehab.


4) Predict the month/year when Nowak will appear on "Oprah" to discuss her problem.

Monday, February 05, 2007

Get the Nobel Committee on the Horn

...Sounds like we've got shoo-in candidates for next year's awards in physics and medicine, thanks to the scientific community in Iran. That country's nut-job president, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, will reportedly unveil "giant achievements" in the coming days, according to the state-run Fars press agency. Fars reports that Iran will make a "dramatic announcement on its nuclear rights on 11 February, part of a series of statements heralding reported technological and medical breakthroughs, including an herbal AIDS cure.

Naturally, the nuclear announcement is drawing the most attention. There's been considerable speculation about what Iran may reveal. The most likely scenario is some sort of announcement hailing the expansion of Tehran's nuclear centrifuge arrays, used to produce highly enriched uranium (HEU) for nuclear power plants--or nuclear weapons. Iran is reportedly planning to increase the number of centrifuges in operation from less than 200 to more than 3,000--a dramatic expansion, but still well below the number required to produce enough HEU for bomb production over the next year. U.S. intelligence agencies still believe that Tehran is 3-4 years away from its first bomb, an estimate that is somewhat consistent with assessments from other experts.

Beyond announcing a centrifuge expansion, Iran may also use the nuclear statement to highlight increased nuclear cooperation with North Korea, or discuss its plans to develop a space launch vehicle (SLV) that could eventually yield an ICBM, capable of hitting targets in the CONUS. As with other Iranian announcements, this one will probably be more hype than substance. But, with its state-run media and the western press acting as little more than stenographers, Tehran can claim almost anything, with little challenge from those in the press.

Iran's claims--however far-fetched--are part of a broad propaganda campaign, designed to create the image of a modern, powerful state, with developing cutting-edge technology that allows it to challenge The Great Satan and Israel. Never mind that Ahmadinejad's so-called "super weapons" are nothing of the sort. As the Nazis demonstrated decades ago, lies repeated often enough are eventually accepted as the truth. The Nobel jurors for the physics prize may not be overly impressed, but Iran's claims will resonate with its target audience in the Middle East and beyond--the same folks who support suicide bombers, global jihad and believe that the U.S. secretly engineered the 9-11 attacks to launch a war against Muslims.

The AIDS "cure" sounds even more luidcrous, but once again, there's a method behind the apparent foolishness. Tehran is aware that President Bush's African AIDS Initiative has won support for the U.S. in a part of the world where Iran also seeks influence. Iran will almost certainly offer its "herbal cure" for free, with none of the scientific or accountability strings attached to western medical programs. And, to sweeten the deal, watch for Ahmadinejad to offer certain "incentives" (read: bribes) for African officials who sign on with the Iranian offer, in return for downsizing (or even rejecting) U.S.-led AIDS programs. Never mind that Tehran's "cure" is almost certainly ineffective. The goal here is regional influence, not healing the sick. If I were the Iranian researcher behind this "cure," I wouldn't make my reservations for Stockhold, at least not yet.

Domestically, Ahmadiejad's AIDS announcement offers a quick solution for one of his country's growing social and public health problems. As outlined in this 2005 report from FrontPage magazine, Iran has a growing number of people affected by the AIDS virus. While overall infection rates remain low (in comparison to the pandemic in southern Africa), Iran's AIDS problem was deemed serious enough to spur public education and needle exchange programs under Ahmadeinjad's predecessor. The pending announcment about a herbal "cure" suggests that the Iran will take a step backward in its efforts to deal with AIDS, trumpeting a quack remedy that will only mask the problem.

BTW, it will be interesting to watch the reaction to the Iranian announcement from AIDS activists in this country. Will they be willing to call it for what it is--a likely fraud--or demand that the FDA grant "fast track" approval for trials/use in the USA.

Changing Tactics--Again

After losing four helicopters to hostile fire in the past two weeks, the U.S. military is vowing to modify its employment tactics.

If this sounds vaguely familiar, it should. There was a similar review and change of tactics in early 2006, after the U.S. lost three helicopters (an AH-64 Apache gunship, an OH-58 Kiowa scout helicopter and a UH-60 Blackhawk transport) in a fourteen-day period. A total of 16 American military personnel died in those incidents; in the latest round of helicopter losses, 21 service members and military contractors have been killed.

The recent spate of shoot-downs has raised the same fears expressed thirteen months ago, namely that insurgents may be using more sophisticated weapons, increasing the potential threat to helicopters and slower-moving conventional aircraft. There is some evidence that Saddam's regime obtained Russian-made SA-18 shoulder-fired SAMs before the U.S.-led invasion in 2003. The SA-18 is a more advanced man-portable missile, with an improved ability to reject aircraft counter-measures. However, to my knowledge, the SA-18 has never been confirmed in the terrorists' arsenal; for the most part, they still rely on older man-portable SAMs (such as the SA-7/14/16), RPGs and automatic weapons fire to engage our aircraft, with middling success.

And that's an important point, one that is always ignored by the MSM. While Reuters notes that "dozens" of U.S. helicopters have been downed by insurgents, they fail to mention that such losses represent only a total fraction of the hundreds of helicopter sorties flown daily in Iraq [emphasis mine]. In fact, cumulative loss rates (per 100,000 hours of flying time) have decreased since the invasion of Iraq in 2003. An occasional spike in chopper losses--tragic though it might be--does little to change those statistics.

Indeed, the recent jump in shootdowns obscures an essential fact, one that you'll never read in a wires service dispatch: Iraq remains a permissive operating environment for U.S. tactical aircraft, allowing us to fly and employ ordnance at will. The terrorists have not been able--nor will they be able--to transform the skies of Iraq into an updated version of the Soviet misadventure in Afghanistan, where American-made Stinger missiles (coupled with poor tactical employment) practically drove Russian helicopters from the skies.

After the slight surge in helicopter losses in 2006, there was a noticeable decrease in successful enemy attacks until the latest rash of shoot-downs last month. That suggests that our earlier "tactical adjustment" achieved its desired goals. For good reason, the military never releases exact details of its modified tactics, but the 2006 adjustment apparently included changes in operating patterns. The U.S. has a long history of operational predictability, and that may be part of the problem in Iraq. Conducting chopper flights at certain times (and along specific flight routes) may be convenient from a scheduling or air traffic control perspective, but it may also allow the enemy to decipher operational patterns, and establish potential ambush times/locations. Creating a little more variance in our ops cycle could (again) go a long way toward reducing helicopter losses.

On the other hand, if the recent shoot-downs are the result of "new" missiles in insurgent hands, well, we have a solution for that problem as well. The U.S. has detailed knowledge of MANPADs made by Russia, China, North Korea and Iran, among other producers. Analysis of fragments and missile warhead remnants, retrieved from the wreckage of the downed choppers, will quickly pin-point which system(s) are responsible, and determine what changes--if any--should be made in our on-board countermeasures and operating tactics. Collectively, that should be enough to minimize the threat, allowing us to continue our highly effective helicopter operations across Iraq.

***
Previous posts on this topic here and here.

Saturday, February 03, 2007

Long Overdue

On the eve of Super Bowl XLI, the NFL released this year's list of selectees for the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Suffice it to say that the list for 2007 is a bit controversial, as it always is. More than a few fans and media types (outside Dallas) expressed misgivings about the selection of former Cowboys wide receiver Michael Irvin, whose off-field problems sometimes overshadowed his accomplishments on the gridiron. Irvin will be enshrined at Canton with lesser numbers than former Redskins' wide receiver Art Monk or Buffalo's great Andre Reed, both of whom were rejected by the selection committee.

There is less controversy surrounding the rest of this year's inductees. Bruce Matthews, the Oilers and Titans lineman started games at all five offensive line positions during a stellar, 19-year career, became only the 60th player to be selected for the Hall of Fame on his first ballot. Other selectees for the Class of 2007 include: Thurman Thomas, the Bills running back who was the league's MVP in 1991, and is one of only three backs to finish with 10,000 yards rushing and over 400 receptions; Roger Wehrli, the St Louis Cardinals cornerback who picked off 40 passes in his career, and was named to the NFL's "All Decade" Team for the 1970s; Charley Sanders, the Detroit Lions tight end who helped redefine that position in a decade-long career that ended in 1977, and Gene Hickerson, the great Cleveland Browns pulling guard who blocked for three Hall of Fame running backs--Jim Brown, Bobby Mitchell and Leroy Kelly.

Among this year's inductees, Hickerson has waited the longest for elevation to the Hall of Fame --29 years. He played his last game with the Browns in 1973, capping a 15-year career with the club. During that tenure, he was named to the Pro Bowl six times, voted to the league's "All Decade" team for the 1960s, and played in four NFL championship games, the forerunner to the Super Bowl.

Such accolades were a testament to Hickerson's skill, in an era when the game was much different. In the run-oriented offenses of the 1960s, offensive guards were prized for their ability to "pull" and lead the sweep, blocking downfield for their running backs. For much of his career, Hickerson was lead blocker for Jim Brown, who still ranks (for my money) as the greatest running back every to play the game. Brown has long maintained that Hickerson belongs in the hall:

"He was one of the best pulling guards that ever played," said Brown, who led the league in rushing eight times. "He had unbelievable speed and mobility and was the best lineman we had. He blocked downfield, something guys today can't do. Nobody knows blockers better than the guys who ran behind him, and I for one am proud that he is in the Hall of Fame. He was the best blocker on a good blocking team."

Hickerson was a product of the University of Mississippi, back in the days when John Vaught's Rebels were a national football power. Vaught favored linemen who were fast and mobile, despite the fact that his teams were better known for their passing attacks, and produced only one thousand-yard rusher in 20 years. Hickerson played fullback at his high school in Tennessee, but switched to tackle at Ole Miss. When the Browns discovered his speed, they moved him to guard, and the rest, as they say, is history.

Well, almost. Browns fans and Hickerson's former teammates have long wondered why it took the Hall of Fame so long to recognize his achievements. Before Hickerson joined the Browns, there had been on seven 1,000-yard rushers in the history of the league; with #66 anchoring the Browns offensive line, Cleveland had nine 1,000-yard runners in Hickerson's first 10 years in the NFL. At the time of Hickerson's retirement, Brown was #1 on the NFL's career rushing list; Leroy Kelly was #4, and Mitchell was bound for Canton as well. But some argued that Brown, whose blend of speed and power revolutionized the running back position, didn't need much of an offensive line to be effective, and neither did Kelly.

The "other" knock against Hickerson and the Browns is that they never won a championship in the early Super Bowl era, dominated by Vince Lombardi's Packers. Green Bay's victories in Super Bowls I and II brought adulation to members of that team, including the Packers' star guard, Jerry Kramer, who wrote about his exploits in the best seller Instant Replay. Kramer's career numbers never matched Hickerson's, but those early championships, coupled with the book's success, led many to equate the "pulling guard" position with Jerry Kramer, and not Gene Hickerson. Asked to describe the difference between Kramer and Hickerson, one veteran NFL writer said: "Gene was a much better player; Jerry wrote a book."

While Hickerson was a finalist for the hall under the "regular" selection process in the early 1980s, the required votes proved elusive, and he reportedly grew bitter over the process. Notified earlier this year that a veteran's committee had again nominated him for Canton, Hickerson replied "I though that was supposed to happen about 20 years ago." Last Saturday, receiving word of his selection, Hickerson was more gracious, saying: "I am honored to be joining such an elite group of individuals and to be remembered as one of the best linemen of all time..It was such a relief to finally get the phone call."

Some would describe it as recognition that is long overdue.

Friday, February 02, 2007

Money Well Spent

Our hearts go out to the victims of today's deadly tornado in Central Florida. The twister was part of a storm system that moved through the area around three a.m. At least fourteen people were killed by the storms, and scores of houses were destroyed. The NWS in Melbourne, FL (which handles storm advisories for the area) says tornado watches were posted hours in advance, and tornado warnings were issued 8-15 minutes before the storm struck.

The problem, of course, is that most people are asleep at three a.m., and never hear those warnings. Making matters worse, many of the communities affected by last night's storm don't have warning sirens.

That's why one of these is a very good investment, especially if you live in an area affected by tornadoes. Thirty bucks is pretty cheap for something that could save your life. But, then again, there's that pesky issue of individual responsibility. I've already heard one Florida resident tell the press that someone should "donate" new homes to persons left homeless by today's storms. Call it a hunch, but something tells me that lady doesn't have a NOAA weather radio on her nightstand.

A Useful First Step, But

From today's Washington Times: It appears the Bush Administration is finally reacting to China's recent ASAT test, beyond those initial statements of concern.

"U.S. Halts China Space Ventures"

Now, let's do something that will really get Beijing's attention--namely, reviving (and fully funding) our own ASAT program.

Support Little Caesars

Super Bowl Sunday is typically the busiest day of the year for the nation's pizza parlors and delivery outlets. Some stores sell as many as 200 pizzas an hour during the big game, more than double the volume of a typical Sunday. To meet the demand, many pizza joints require all personnel to work on Super Bowl Sunday, offering extra pay and other incentives to get workers to show up.

Sometime before kick-off Sunday, I'll probably pick up the phone and order a pie. But instead of calling the usual place, I think I'll get my Super Bowl pizza from Little Caesars. That's because the Detroit-based chain and its owner, Mike Ilitch, have launched a program to help veterans--particularly disabled veterans--find new careers as franchisees for the company. While all qualified veterans receive discounts on the franchise fee and initial equipment order, disabled veterans are eligible for other benefits, including a waived franchise fee ($20,000), a $10,000 credit on their initial equipment, and start-up marketing support. The total benefit for sevice-disabled veterans can total $68,000.

Former Army Staff Sergeant Robbie Doughty lost both of his legs to a roadside bomb in Iraq. Yesterday, he opened a Little Caesar's store in his hometown of Paducah, Kentucky. In some respects, Sergeant Doughty is responsible for the company's veterans program. Mike Ilitch read a profile of Doughty in USA Today in 2004, and was so moved by the soldier's courage and determination that he called Doughty to thank him for his service to our nation. That sparked a series of conversations that eventually led to the Veteran's Program, and Thursday's grand opening in Paducah.

If your neighborhood's like mine, there are probably five or six pizza joints within 10 miles of your home. No shortage of options for the Super Bowl pizza. But if you decide to buy a pie on Sunday, think about giving the business to your local Little Caesars store, and support a company that is truly supporting our troops.

***

More on the program--and Sergeant Doughty--from this recent Mitch Albom column in the Detroit Free Press.

How Much Do Teachers Make?

Today's Opinion Journal offers a summary of a recently-released study on teacher pay in America. And, it's safe to say that the National Education Association (NEA), the nation's largest teacher's union, won't like it one bit.

According to the authors of the study, Jay P. Greene and Marcus Winters, the "average" classroom teacher in America earns $34.06 an hour in 2005. And that number isn't something that Professor Greene or Mr. Winters simply pulled out of a hat; it's based on hard data from federal government's Bureau of Labor Statistics. The bureau also determined that the median teacher wage is 36% higher than the hourly compensation rate for an average white collar worker, and 11% higher than than the hourly wage for an average professional or technical worker. In terms of hourly pay, most teachers are not underpaid.

Of course, there is a slight catch in these figures, since they're based on the number of hours actually worked. Many teachers are off in the summer, and have lengthy breaks at the end of the year and in the spring. Dividing a teacher's salary over a 12-month period, the hourly compensation rate begins to decline. But, as Greene and Winters note, many educators supplement their income by teaching in summer school programs, or working another job. Those wages (which are also excluded from the compensation calculation) would tend to push hourly pay rates back toward the national average, or in some cases, above the $34.06 level cited by the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Greene and Winters argue that the compensation debate is important for a couple of reasons. First, there is a long-standing perception that teachers are underpaid for their labors, and secondly, Congressional efforts to extend the "No Child Left Behind" program are expected to focus on the pay issue, with likely proposals to increase teacher salaries across the board. The NEA and American Federation of Teachers would certainly like to shape the debate in those terms, but is it the best approach for fixing failing schools?

According to Greene and Winters, the answer to that question is a resounding "no." As they observe, teacher compensation has been (historically) linked to the number of years spent in the classroom, and the amount of advanced education and certifications earned by educators. They believe that teacher pay should be linked to student achievement, following the example of a pilot programs in Arkansas and Florida. In the Arkansas study (which Greene and Winters helped direct), researchers found that student proficiency increased (and scores on standardized tests rose) when teachers received bonuses linked to student performance. The Florida program achieved similar results.

As a "reformed" educator, I find Greene and Winters's arguments to be compelling. We can debate teacher pay levels all day, but there's no doubt that compensation benchmarks for educators are in need of serious reform. In most districts, even the most gifted teachers still make less money than their peers if they lack a graduate degree, certain certifications, or simply haven't spent as much time in the classroom. And, not surprisingly, those are the very teachers who often leave the classroom after a few years, deciding that their skills can secure better pay and benefits in the private sector.

At the other end of the spectrum, veteran teachers who earn the highest salaries are, in some cases, less likely to remain in the classroom. After "proving" themselves in the classroom, many teachers move on to supervisory and administrative positions that don't include any instructional duties. At the last school were I worked, our two best teachers were the principal and the athletic director. Together, they had more than 40 years of classroom experience. And quite naturally, they had no desire to give up their administrative posts and return to the classroom. Unfortunately, this "cycle" helps perpetuate many of the problems evident in our educational system, where the best teachers often work in non-teaching positions. The quality of instruction suffers under this approach, and test scores remain stagnant.

Linking teacher pay to test scores could be an effective means for rewarding our best teachers, and keeping them in the classroom. Unfortunately, the approach favored by Greene, Winters and other education reformers will never get a fair hearing from the NEA, and their Democratic friends in Congress. As for the White House, President Bush sees "No Child Left Behind" as one of his legacies, and a desire to see the program continue (coupled with the power shift in Congress) leaves him unwilling to take on the education establishment. An extension of "No Child Left Behind" will almost certainly include teacher pay raises, but they probably won't reward the educators who actually make a difference, sparking student skills and achievement that can be quantified by standardized tests.

***

Addendum: The Green-Winters study also refutes one of the classic arguments for increased teacher pay, the fact that many educators spend a good chunk of their free time on job-related tasks, such as grading papers or developing lesson plans. As the authors note, many professionals take their work home at night, and their compensation packages (typically) don't reward the extra effort, either.

Thursday, February 01, 2007

What's Missing From This Story (Corporate Edition)?

Take a look at this article, from AP "Business Writer" John Porretto.

"Exxon-Mobil Posts Record Profit."

As you read, you'll discover that the world's largest oil company earned the largest profit in U.S. corporate history last year--$39.5 billion.

I can already predict the collective reaction from the MSM and the public. Why, those greedy oil companies. They're gouging us, with Exxon-Mobil in the lead. Mr. Porretto helpfully reminds us that Exxon-Mobil also set the old records for earnings and profits, implying that the "Biggest of Big Oil" has been screwing us for some time.

But here's a question for you--and Mr. Porretto:

How much does Exxon-Mobil (and the other oil companies) pay in corporate income taxes during a year?

Quite a bit, it turns out. According to the Tax Foundation, Exxon-Mobil's corporate tax bill in 2005 (the most recent year for which data is available) was $23.1 billion, on a before-tax income of $59.1 billion. Exxon-Mobil's effective corporate tax rate in 2005 was 39.1%. Collectively, the nation's three largest oil companies (Exxon-Mobil, Chevron and ConocoPhillips) paid $44.3 billion in corporate income tax that year, with an average tax rate of 41%.

But you'll never read that in an AP business story. Just lots of big numbers that create the impression of gargantuan profits, and the need for a windfall profits tax.

I'd say $44.3 billion is a pretty sizeable windfall. But then again, I'm not a member of Congress---or a writer for the AP.

Second Time's the Charm?

Rumor of the Day: A little over two years ago, Don Rumsfeld and the White House tried to break the Navy's stranglehold over leadership of U.S. Pacific Command (PACOM), nominating Air Force General Gregory "Speedy" Martin as the next CINCPAC. Unfortunately, General Martin's nomination was eventually scuttled, due to his association with the Air Force/Boeing tanker scandal. Never mind that General Martin was never accused of any wrong doing; his limited involvement with the program was enough to convince John McCain that Martin was not suitable for the CINCPAC job. Martin retired, and two Navy admirals have held the post since that time. As we observed at the time, Senator McCain was hardly a disinterested observer, as a retired Navy Captain, and a son of a former CINCPAC.

Now, Defense Secretary Robert Gates may be preparing another attempt to end the Navy's dominance at PACOM. The buzz in the Pentagon suggests that Air Force Lieutenant General David Deptula may have the inside track at becoming the next CINCPAC, replacing Admiral William Fallon. Admiral Fallon got the top job at CINCPAC when General Martin's nomination was withdrawn, and more recently, he has been nominated to replace General Abizaid at U.S. Central Command. Deptula, who currently serves as the Air Force's Deputy Chief of Staff for Intelligence, is a former Vice Commander of U.S. Pacific Air Forces.

This recent article in the Honolulu Advertiser lists all the potential nominees, and suggests that Deptula is something of a dark horse candidate. Virtually all of the other prospective nominees --including the Navy candidates--already have their fourth star. But with the growing emphasis on air and space power in the Pacific (to counter threats from China and North Korea), Mr. Gates may decide that it's time for an Air Force officer to lead the command. General Deptula, who's been on the "star" track since his days as a primary air planner in Riyadh during Operation Desert Storm, is supremely qualified to be the next CINCPAC. We'll soon see if Secretary Gates--and the President--agree.

Duh

The "non-partisan" Congressional Budget Office claims that the actual size of the troop surge in Iraq may be much higher than estimates provided by the White House. According to the CBO, the number of additional soldiers and Marines going to Iraq may be as high as 48,000, when support units and their personnel are factored into the equation.

Our response can be summed up in one word: Duh.

Even the folks at the CBO should understand that any "trigger-puller" formation requires extensive support from medical personnel, finance types, maintenance specialists, cooks, transporters, intelligence analysts, communications technicians and a host of other support branches. A combat brigade may have limited capabilities in some of these areas (such as intel and maintenance), but providing the full range of support services requires the deployment of support units.

During World War II, there were 6-7 support troops for every soldier at the front; if the Pentagon can pull off the surge with only 48,000 soldiers and Marines (a 1.-1.3 shooter-to-support ratio), that's a fairly lean operation. Of course, there are large numbers of support troops already in Iraq, meaning the 28,000 non-combat personnel will largely augment--and expand--the extensive support structure already in place.

Critics will claim that the Bush Administration deliberately excluded the support troops from its surge total, hoping to make the deployment look "smaller," and gain support for the plan. On the other hand, you could also say that this "revelation" is another example of a MSM that knows virtually nothing about the military. Here's a transcript of the 11 January Pentagon press conference that covered the troop surge. You'll note that only one question covered the size of the deployment, and there were no queries about the number of additional support personnel required to support those combat brigades. Such is the state of military reporting in the MSM. Thank God for the blogosphere.

***

On a related note, the departing U.S. commander in Iraq, General George Casey, told the Senate Armed Service Committee that securing Baghdad could be accomplished with "fewer than half" the troops that will be added in the surge. General Casey made the comments before the Senate panel this morning, during hearings on his nomiation to be the next Army Chief of Staff.

Asked by Sen. John Warner, R-Va., why he had not requested the full five extra brigades that Bush is sending, Casey said, "I did not want to bring one more American soldier into Iraq than was necessary to accomplish the mission."

With many in Congress opposing or skeptical of Bush's troop buildup, Casey did not say he opposed the president's decision. He said the full complement of five brigades would give U.S. commanders in Iraq additional, useful flexibility.

"In my mind, the other three brigades should be called forward after an assessment has been made on the ground" about whether they are needed to ensure success in Baghdad, Casey said later.

Casey and the outgoing CENTCOM commander, General John Abizaid, have long insisted that Baghdad could be secured without a larger troop build-up. General Casey's replacement in Iraq, Lt Gen David Petraeus, has voiced strong support for the planned surge, and a more aggressive approach in securing Iraq's most violent districts.

Some members of the Senate have openly questioned whether Casey should be the next Army Chief of Staff, given the escalation in violence during his tenure in Iraq, and his apparent disagreement with the troop surge. But the the Army CofS does not manage combat campaigns; his job is to organize, train and equip forces for combatant commanders. By most estimates, Casey did an excellent job in his last job before the Iraq assignment, when he served as the Army's Vice Chief of Staff.

General Casey seems to have the right skills to be an effective Chief of Staff, a job that will be even more important as the U.S. begins to drawdown in Iraq. In the aftermath of that conflict, the Army will have to spend billions on recapitalization, to repair or replace equipment that was damaged or destroyed in Iraq. Casey will also face the task of keeping qualified soldiers in uniform, and adding another 65,000 troops to the Army's ranks, part of the force expansion recently announced by President Bush. Meeting the recapitalization and recruiting requirements are the two most important challenges facing the next Army Chief of Staff, and General Casey is, arguably, the best man to handle those assignments.

One final thought: Casey's nomination for CofS may also reflect the administration's continued dissatisfaction with the current "crop" of Army leadership. Former Defense Secretary Don Rumsfeld fought pitched battles with Army generals over plans for the invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq, and (in an obvious slap at the service's senior military leaders) he brought General Peter Schoomaker out of retirement to serve as CofS in 2003. With Schoomaker now ready for his second retirement, it's doubtful that the Senate will reject Casey's nomination as Chief of Staff. But it will be interesting to see how Casey fares in his full Senate vote. One thing's for certain; he will not get the unanimous support that David Petraeus received when he was approved as Casey's replacement in Iraq.

All the Facts that Fit the Template

Reuters' latest dispatch from Baghdad trumpets more bad news:

"Blasts hit Baghdad as deaths hit new high"

Citing Interior Ministry sources, the wire service notes that the number of civilian fatalities in Iraq "edged up to another record in January." According to the Interior Ministry, 1,971 civilians were killed by terrorism last month, up slightly from December's total (1930).

But the United Nations, which compiles its own data, showed a decrease in the number of civilian deaths, with 2,914 recorded in January, compared to 3,462 in the previous month. To its credit, Reueters notes that these statistics are controversial, and often inaccurate. Officially, the Iraqi government has quit providing monthly totals for the numbers of civilians dead, and the U.S. military has never provided those statistics. Instead, Reuters gets its information from anonmyous officials within the interior ministry, with no independent verification.

In fact, these statistics are largely useless, since they offer no breakout of the number of civilians killed by terrorists (read: Al Qaida), and those who die in sectarian violence. But Reuters is happy to print the information anyway, since it reinforces public perceptions of a country where violence is rampant, and security remains elusive.

Careful readers may also notice that something else is missing from this story. Typically, end-of-the-month casualty counts from Iraq also include the number of U.S. military fatalities, particularly if it's been a bad month on the ground. So, how many of our military personnel died in Iraq last month? According to the Iraq Coalition Casualty Count website, the number of military fatalities in Iraq during January was 84, compared to 112 in December.

That decrease is notable for several reasons; first, it occurred as U.S. forces began the recently-announced troops surge, with more troops arriving in theater, and an upswing in activities aimed at rooting out the terrorists. More troops in the field, patrolling more actively = a greater risk of casualties. Secondly, a significant portion of the January death toll was the result of a single incident--the crash of a Blackhawk helicopter on 20 January that killed 13 soldiers. Hostile fire is believed responsible for that incident, the deadliest helicopter crash in Iraq in almost a year.

Obviously, we grieve for all our fallen heroes, and look forward to the day when we won't be reporting monthly death statistics in Iraq. And, while the January decrease is encouraging, we shouldn't read too much into those numbers--unless the trend continues for several months. Indeed, the number of combat casualties may actually increase over the short term, as the troop surge continues, and we increase our security presence in some of Iraq's most dangerous neighborhoods. In the interim, it is rather interesting--but hardly a surprise--that Reuters excluded the drop in military fatalities from monthly death toll round-up. When you're trying to fit a particular template, reporters must be careful in choosing the news they elect to report.

Ingrates in Uniform

That should be the title of the latest blog entry from William Arkin of the Washington Post, who writes on national and homeland security matters for the paper. Mr. Arkin is apparently upset over a piece that aired last Friday, on NBC Nightly News. In that segment, reporter Richard Engel interviewed U.S. soldiers currently serving in Iraq. To a man, they expressed frustration over war critics who "support the troops" while denouncing the military campaign they are attempting to execute. A young enlisted man, 21-year-old Tyler Johnson, summed it up well, telling Mr. Engel:

"You may support or say we support the troops, but, so you're not supporting what they do, what they're here sweating for, what we bleed for, what we die for. It just don't make sense to me," Johnson said.

Apparently, such sentiments are a bit too much for Mr. Arkin. He believes the troops should be happy that the public still supports them.

These soldiers should be grateful that the American public, which by all polls overwhelmingly disapproves of the Iraq war and the President's handling of it, do still offer their support to them, and their respect.

Through every Abu Ghraib and Haditha, through every rape and murder, the American public has indulged those in uniform, accepting that the incidents were the product of bad apples or even of some administration or command order.

If your blood's not boiling yet, it will be. After insulting every man and woman who has served honorably in Iraq--99.999999% of the total--Arkin accuses them of being ingrates, given the swell deal they get from Uncle Sam.

"So, we pay the soldiers a decent wage, take care of their families, provide them with housing and medical care and vast social support systems and ship obscene amenities into the war zone for them, we support them in every possible way, and their attitude is that we should in addition roll over and play dead, defer to the military and the generals and let them fight their war, and give up our rights and responsibilities to speak up because they are above society?"

But Arkin still had one last salvo for those who serve:

But it is the United States and instead this NBC report is just an ugly reminder of the price we pay for a mercenary - oops sorry, volunteer - force that thinks it is doing the dirty work.

According to his biography, Mr. Arkin served one tour in the post-Vietnam Army, from 1974-1978. A few years ago, after Arkin launched an offensive against a senior intelligence officer who openly espoused his Christian faith, Hugh Hewitt did a little digging on the national security analyst. Seems that most of his recent "experience" in national security matters has been with organizations like Greenpeace and Human Rights Watch, so his anti-military tone should come as no surprise.

Where to begin? Let's start with the low-hanging fruit, the "decent wages" assertion. Pick up a copy of the military Times' annual survey of military and civilian compensation. At every rank --from buck private, to four-star general, military personnel typically earn less than their civilian counterparts. More than 10,000 of our youngest troops, married with young children, are eligible for food stamps. And, of course, when they're not counting their riches or looking for tax shelters, those who wear uniform still have to put up with the other "distractions" of a mercenary career, namely months away from home (in such garden spots as Iraq and Afghanistan), and the possibility that you may be killed or maimed by the enemy.

But hey, when you return from your third or fourth rotation to the Middle East, you can kick back in your comfortable base quarters and relax, right? Military housing has come a long way over the past 20 years, but for mid-level NCOs and company-grade officers, it's still no better than an entry-level house or condo. Yeah, there's no charge for rent or utilities, but accepting base housing also means that you don't draw your housing allowance or locality "adjustment," so your paycheck isn't as big as it could be.

Making matters worse, many of our military installations are located in high-cost-of-living areas, and junior enlisted members--the same ones getting food stamps--have to wait months for base housing. In the interim, young wives often live paycheck-to-paycheck, caring for small children while their husbands are away. As Mrs. Spook would attest (along with thousands of current and former military spouses), it's a very tough life, but one they accepted in support of their husband's or wife's military career. But until Mr. Arkin came along, most didn't realize they were living the life of luxury.

Free medical care? The operative word here is "free." Get on the phone 30 minutes before the base primary care clinic opens, and hope you get an appointment. If you're lucky, you'll get to see a provider that day. Your other option (as a military member) is to show up for sick call, then spend most of your morning or afternoon waiting to be seen. In many cases you won't see a doctor (the military prefers physicians' assistants and nurse practitioners--they're cheaper). Referral to a specialist means a trip off-base (and money out of your pocket), or a drive to another military installation, often hours away. And don't expect to find all of the latest medications at your base pharmacy. Years ago, one of my kids took Acutane for acne; it was too pricey for the installation's pharmacy, so I paid for it myself, and waited two months for the Air Force to reimburse me. Ah, the good old days.

Those "vast support social support systems?" Many are manned by volunteers, or handled by the units themselves. I've known more than a few commanders' spouses who run the support network for the unit, helping families during deployments. They don't wear the uniform, or earn a dime from the government, but they make themselves available to help a young soldier's wife get her car fixed, or help another military spouse through a family crisis.

Life in the military is far from idyllic--and most of us understand that when we raise our right hand and take that enlistment oath. But we also understand that ours is a calling, not a job, and we're willing (if necessary) to put our lives on the line, in support of our comrades, and in defense of ideals that we hold dear. Military members are not "above" our society; they are a product of that society. While those who serve understand that Mr. Arkin has a right to his opinion (however repugnant it may be), they also appreciate the irony illustrated by his feckless opinion piece. Our best and brightest in uniform--like Specialist Johnson in Iraq--are fighting not only to promote liberty and freedom in a voliatle region, they are also fighting to defend fools like William Arkin, a man who is unworthy of their sacrifice.

***

More thoughts on Mr. Arkin from Powerline, Michelle Malkin (who has a great shot of the "creature comforts" enjoyed by our Marines on patrol); Ed Morrissey and my personal favorite, Uncle Jimbo at Blackfive.